I wanted so much to love this film. I didn't!!!

Rating: 3/10 (23 December 2007)

I have been anticipating the opening of "Sweeney Todd" for the last several weeks. Being a true fan of Sondheim and of "Sweeney Todd", I was excited to see Tim Burton's version. I knew it would be visually stunning and it was. Each frame a visual feast. I was quite disappointed, however in the lack of passion and strength in the performances. Johnny Depp's portrayal of "Sweeney Todd" lacked the drive and lust that the character requires. This lack of passion and vocal talent was evident throughout. This was most evident when Sweeney is reunited with his razors. That moment should raise the hairs on the back of the neck of anyone watching. Johnny Depp just couldn't take us there. Helena's Mrs. Lovett lacked the crazy, fun, lighthearted feel of the original Angela Landsbury performance. Often times she missed important moments in which humor could break the monotonous dark overtones. I believe Meryl Streep would have been a better choice. The kid playing Toby had a great singing voice and did his best, but in my opinion was too young for the part. I just didn't believe "Nothin's gonna harm you". Now for the blood. It was too much and too often. We got the hint after the first kill, must we be beaten in the head with it over and over again. It was not necessary and detracted greatly. On a high note the characters of Anthony, Johanna and Beedle were played to perfection. Well-cast and well acted. I can see how people who were not previously familiar with "Sweeney Todd" could give it high marks. But for those of us who have seen stage productions of this fantastic musical, and sat glued to our seats at the beautiful and haunting melodies, the deep rich voices, the passion and the polish, we can't be anything but a bit disappointed.