A wonderful film ruined by the most soulless music ever

Rating: 5/10 (20 November 2008)

Excellent cast.
Excellent directing.
Excellent cinematography.
Excellent story.
Lousy music.
Don't get me wrong; the music was well crafted. The arrangements were meticulous, and the lyrics were at times clever. But let this be an example: smooth polish and technical perfection does not make a good song. Without any soul; without any memorable melody, the songs are only fit for elevator music.
"Sweeny Todd" would have been a great movie without the lame tunes, but instead it turned out to be a very poor musical. George & Ira, rest easy. No one will be taking your crown away any time soon.