Singing better than the original!

Rating: 10/10 (30 January 2008)

Most musicals put to the screen are disappointing to me because the singers are never, ever as good as the original cast. Phantom was dreadful. However, Depp and Carter give the music a real "lowtown" quality-and they can carry a tune. Their chemistry was great. The casting of this movie was perfect. I would suggest not waiting for the video to come out. The experience of this movie should take place on the big screen with all the sound that comes with it. I know my 14 year old daughter would love this as we enjoy musicals together. She probably won't see it for a while because of the gore. I will see it as many times as I can. A definite iTunes purchase for the soundtrack as well.