Are these bad reviews written by George Lucas?

Rating: 8/10 (29 December 2015)

Okay, first off, is it a perfect movie? No.
But after reading some reviews on here you would swear they based the movie on Jar Jar Binks and it was a sing-along, frozen-like musical.
Really people?
I went into this movie with high expectations and I wasn't let down. First of all, JJ Abrams going back to practical effects was a brilliant decision. Because the effects were practical and didn't seem so blatantly fake or green-screened like the prequels, it allowed the viewer to immerse themselves in the movie rather than be distracted by special effects.
SPOILERS BELOW!! SPOILERS BELOW!!
The new characters blended and interacted with the old ones so well and our new cast delivered a great performance. I thought that the character Kylo Ren was played very well and you can feel his confusion and the struggle that he's going through fighting the light in himself. I think the reason that people are disappointed with Kylo Ren is because when they saw the trailer, they saw a sinister mask staring at them (reminiscent of Darth Vader) and he delivers the line, "I will finish what you started" as the view changes to a shot of Vader's melted mask. People saw that and expected a terrifyingly powerful Sith who is more ruthless than Vader was and instead the character is a very untrained and inexperience 20-something that is struggling with inner conflict.
My question to the negative reviewers...why is this a bad thing?
Think back to the original trilogy. What did we know about Darth Vader in A New Hope? Nothing. We knew that he was an intimidating leader but that's it really. It's not until episodes 5 and 6 that we learn a little more but even then the main thing we know about Vader is that he's Luke's father. This creates internal struggle for both Luke and Vader through the rest of the trilogy that finally comes full circle with their final fight.
The point I'm making is that in the all-holy original trilogy, it took until towards the end of episode 5 to feel the internal struggle of the main characters. With The Force Awakens, we get it right away which allows us to immediately immerse ourselves into the feelings of Kylo Ren and his struggle.
Now, as for the now infamous light saber duel between Kylo Ren and Rey. This was beautiful.
After reading the complaints, I feel like the negativity is from a bunch of 16-20-something year olds that grew up with the prequels who expect everybody who holds a light saber to be an incredibly well trained and experienced Jedi/Sith and for the duel do be this acrobatic, well-choreographed battle.
The beauty of the Ren/Rey duel is that neither of them is that well trained in the use of a light saber and it shows! Ren Killed off the new Jedi order and forced Luke into hiding before he was even trained properly. As for Rey, the explanation would be that she has an incredibly high meticlorien count (most likely because she is probably Luke's daughter). When Ren tried to read her mind, he AWOKE the force inside her and allowed her to tap into the force. Their duel wasn't some wild saber fight...instead it was more hacking and random swinging that ended with Rey tapping into the force to defeat Kylo Ren. The point the duel made was that Kylo Ren has a long way to go -and- that Rey is more powerful than she knows.
What that duel showed us is that the next movie is incredibly important to the fate of the third movie. Rey will be trained by Luke Skywalker and Ren will finish his training with Snoke. There will be another light saber/force battle in the 2nd movie and I predict that Kylo Ren will win. (The Dark Side of the force will become stronger in him after killing his father the same way it grew stronger in Anakin after killing off the Jedi and the remnants of the trade federation).
I would also like to give credit to JJ Abrams and the entire team for how they carried out the duel and how it played into the story. After watching the trailer and seeing Fin with the light saber, the expectation going into the movie was that he would be the main character and that he would become a Jedi....total bait and switch and it was beautiful.
As for pretty much everything else, I thought the whole cast and crew executed the movie beautifully. The visuals were stunning and not distracting. It tapped into the perfect amount of nostalgia while also creating new characters for us to root for and hate. All in all, you can say it was a remake or that it was too much like Ep. 4 but the funny thing about it is that had they deviated from the original trilogy, a lot of you would be complaining and calling it a new "prequels" and bashing it for that.
Lets appreciate that this was the first movie in what looks to be a VERY promising new trilogy. I personally can't wait for the next episode.