Darth Vader Rising....

Rating: 10/10 (20 May 2005)

OK now for all these people giving it a 1/10 and going on and on about how much better the original trilogy was. Sure it was great and it was what got us hooked on the Saga to begin with but come on to say that ROTS pails in comparison to those and go so far as to rate is 1/10 (not even Maid in Manhatten is ratted that bad) is really something. It does show something is going down, and no its the films quality its the IQ of these people. Seriously what are you on??? Sure the dialog isn't that great and sometimes the acting isn't too much to talk about, but even the original trilogy had its downsides. Come on one seconds the Ewoks are cannibals about to cook Hans, Leia and Luke and the next they are Saviors of the Galaxy. Seriously thats always been the beauty of these movies, they have their lapses but they make up for it and much much more with all the fights, the talk of the greater good and the sacrifices we witness. And really even Empire's "... I am your father..." scene doesn't come close to the rise of Vader and Padmi's death. The chills you feel as Vader dons the back suit, and Luke it held by him Aunt and Uncle in Tatooine is really really something special, and if you were really a true fan of the original trilogy you would go unmoved by it. So please if you just nostalgic about the 70s and want to recreate some magic from those times, just go to the disco, don't go bad mouthing one of the best work of our generation.