It was almost the greatest!

Rating: 9/10 (4 December 2005)

I really did love this film, and had much anticipation about it. The one thing that that kept me from giving it a ten out of ten was...Hayden Christensen. He was not convincing to me. I never felt that He became Vader until He was burned up and growling "I hate You!" to Obi Wan. The majority of the rest of the characters were compelling and believable. (Even your CGI characters) I feel that the actor who should have played Vader prior to being placed in the suit should have made me shudder just like he did when I was seven years old. It is still one of the greatest movies in my mind, but does not top my list by any means.