Better than 1 and 2, but still disappointing.

Rating: 6/10 (19 May 2005)

Visual effects alone do not make a movie. George Lucas should've learned this after Jar-Jar Binks bombed in Episode 1.
What I didn't like... I know many of you are die-hard Star Wars fans, but those who are not blinded by the force should admit that this is an average movie. Good special effects, but (in my opinion) not as good as Lord of the Rings. I felt that the dialogue was awful and very awkward. It as if it was written by a young child as his first story.
What I liked...
I like how episode 3 was tied to 4. I think the transition was well done. I like the "birth of Darth Vader." It was pretty cool to see how he comes about. I also liked the light saber scenes. Oh yeah, and any scene with Yoda was good as well. They were some of the more enjoyable parts of an average movie.
After seeing Episode 3, I think I was more excited about the trailers for Batman, War of the Worlds, Narnia, Fantastic 4, and Mr. and Mrs. Smith.
Well, this is my (humble) opinion. May the force be with you.