The best star wars film (of the first 3 episodes of course)

Rating: 8/10 (24 May 2005)

Its a far better movie than episode 1 and 2
We all know that Lucas is a bad actors' director - he has some good talent there (McGregor, Portman, Christensen) but doesn't utilize them at all... McDiarmid is excellent - his superior talent rises above all the movie (note: I can't understand the guy that commended that he is the worse in this one - he is The Emperor - he was born for the role).
Where "Sith" is successful is that it tells the story we all expected to watch but still keeps you at the edge of the sit so that you see how Lucas will realize that story... It also surpasses the other 2 episodes because - although the acting is below par - its again above "menace" and "clones"...
Most of you also criticized the movie of being "too-much CGI" - I find the CGI in this movie effective - cause I believe that the vast fantasy in Lucas's head couldn't be shown on film in any other way (OK maybe he goes a bit crazy with it, as he was deprived of it back in 1977).