Whiners

Rating: 10/10 (21 June 2005)

Attention everyone! I have just a few things to say, first shut up, and second the movie is great! I checked out how many people that had given it a good review and how many that had given it a bad review, not to surprising it had gotten good reviews from the general public, overall at least..... To those people who whine about that most seem to think it's a good film, learn to be tactical and diplomatic or else i will have to consider you to be utterly stupid! If you don't like the movie just say so, don't go around insulting those who do, that doesn't get you anywhere! As a person who is very well learned in most areas, i know it's strange cause i'm only 19, but i have actually gotten scholarships because of my speaking skills, writing skills and general learning so in some measure i do know what i'm talking about but i'm definitely not an expert, i am just surprised at some peoples reactions against the movie. Now keep in mind that i can perfectly understand why you think as you do, but i can take the things you complain about and show you why they're good. The dialog is the way it is because of the sources of George Lucas inspiration. I'm call myself a cineast, i collect Kurosawa films, old German silent movies and modern french, Japanese and American movies. As i have watched much old or if you want ancient movies i can see directly what George Lucas is trying to do. He is trying to recreate his childhood matinées with their stiff dialog which is very difficult to master. Also keep in mind that even though not all of the acting is meant to be like this, some actors aren't actually that good and when this is the case, it shows. Also keep in mind that not all people are fit to act in front of a blue screen, it's actually pretty hard. But this is not the case in the entire movie and i understand why those of you who don't know the old movie industry as i and some of my friends do can't see that, if i wasn't so interested in old movies i might also perceive this to be bad acting, i don't know..... As for those of you who are older and don't like the movies, i call it the loss of the inner child complex, you watched the movies when you were little but now that you've gotten older and "more mature" you can't bring yourself to like these movies, maybe because of that you haven't grown up with technology as todays youths or maybe because of sheer stubbornness i don't know. Or it might actually be so that i doesn't fit your personal taste, it's impossible for everyone to like a movie. But to look at the facts, the movie has gotten almost only good reviews, here in Sweden it has a grade of 9,34 out of ten from the cinema-goers and it's not that different in other countries either, in France it is the first American film to have so many visitors and the same for six other European countries. For you who says that it isn't deep, please! The inner conflict is magnificent, Palpatine aka Ian Mcdiarmid shows the emotional plot of the film with every gesture, every move and Natalie Portman plays better than any of the great female stars of old, well maybe not better than Ingrid Bergman and Liz Taylor, butt still! These movies are for people who still likes to imagine, people who are creative, as the special effects are creative and groundbreaking, so is the movie. So for those who complain about others giving it good grades, shut up, we've only seen something that you have missed or forgotten or just doesn't like......