Not Even the Best of the Prequels - Although the Darkest

Rating: 5/10 (17 September 2005)

When one goes to see a Star Wars film it is not to watch excellent acting or excellent dialogue. As expected, both of those categories are pretty awful. It is expected, however, to have lots of action, excellent special effects, neat characters and aliens, and an interesting story. Unfortunately, Revenge of the Sith fails.
The beginning depicts a big space battle that does offer excitement. With a keen eye, however, its plain to see where the special effects are not that special. In particular, the Republic star fighters remain stationary in the shot as the camera and background move about them. This thereby compromises the illusion of reality. Such failures can be noticed throughout the movie.
Yet there is still the possibility for new aliens and characters or at least a good story. While there are some new aliens and characters, few capture the imagination or heart. As for the story, Lucas is so intent upon bridging the gap from "Attack of the Clones" to "A New Hope" that he forgets that he is making a movie. He additionally forgets that there were five other movies beforehand that contradict things in this movie. This ultimately leads to a contrived story.
There is, however a glimpse of interest when Palpatine talks about a masterful Sith. This alludes to a history of the Universe that can be played out for quite some time. Additionally, there is plenty of action and eye candy.
Revenge of the Sith therefore tries to be a standard Star Wars movie. While offering some of the elements one has come to expect, it creates voids elsewhere.