The Best of the Series

Rating: 9/10 (19 May 2005)

First off, this is an incredible piece of work - the special effects are truly amazing. But its the story that really stands out. Lucas has created a tragedy of Shakespearian vision. There are several moments in particular - Anakin intervening in the Windu battle, and the jedi temple slaughter, that have an emotional power that has only on occasion reared itself - at the end of Empire, and the end of Jedi.
It is a very satisfying film, with good combat sequences, and better duels, though I was a little disappointed with the Windu vs Sidious battle. Padme's ultimately fatal journey through the film was very moving, and allowed her to flex her acting muscles - something that she had been unable to do effectively in the last two films. Indeed, the acting in general was fine, with Hayden and Ewan doing good work, though I still think somebody else should have played Anakin - Hayden, even in this film, was still a little whelpy in the first half.
As for faults, the script in the first half was a little contrived - 'It's because I'm so in love'/'No, it's because I'm so in love with you'. I'd like to see Pacino deliver that line convincingly. Also, the darth Varder 'Noooo' was embarrassing.
Still, an excellent,entertaining movie, and in my humble opinion, the best in the series. Just needed Han Solo, and it would of been awesome.