Illogical and inconsistent - Good for kids, should be an animated Disney Classic

Rating: 3/10 (10 September 2005)

Count Duku: a great actor like C. Lee, I would at least let him play throughout the film and not kill him off in the first 20 minutes.
How come Duku dies so easily? Even when Anakin holds two light sabers to his head can he not use the force as he, and others have literally done throughout? A quick backwards flip? Where is the Lightning Force when you need it? And what happened to Obi Wan all this time. He is knocked out and unable to help as usual. And with all their power and droid army why not just get 100 of them to blast the two lone jedis instead of Count Duku trying to take them on solo.
How about Padme. We are expected to believe that she will die during childbirth? Excuse me? No doctors around? Mankind has managed to build space crafts that travel at light speed, but cannot master knowledge and technology to save a pregnant woman? Windu tries to arrest Palpatine who is the most powerful Sith Lord and he goes in with 4 hapless jedis who get dispatched in a shot. Might as well have sent the cleaners to arrest him.
Who is most powerful and who uses the Force best? Windu? Palpatine? Obi Wan? Yoda? Any of the other jedis? In the last episode we saw Palpatine to be leagues ahead of both Vader and Luke, using the Lightning Force never seen before. Yoda cannot beat him, otherwise he would not be hiding alone in a planet (without any companions of his own species). At the same time Yoda is strong enough to raise a drowned X-Wing. That is the extend of the power of Palpatine. Count Duku is as strong as Yoda, Yoda is as strong as Windu, Windu is stronger than Palpatine, but Yoda and Obi Wan together cannot fight Palpatine in Episode VI. Inconsistencies throughout.
The fight between Windu and Palpatine is awful. Windu beats him, even when Palpatine uses the lighting force against him. Which he waits until Anaken is in the room, and not before, to save himself. And it only gets reflected back to him ageing him in the process. So why does he not stop? At least in the Duku vs Yoda fight we had enough Lightning Force to go around, even though, there too, they just decided not to use it and instead use their light sabers, as if anything would be preventing them from using the Lightning Force in between.
I have not seen past the Windu vs Palpatine scene - I switched it off in disgust. What kind of slimy and stupid transformation of Anakin.
Just one possible way of how it should be: (1) Palpatine is so strong and can use the Lightining Force that No one else can use. No one can beat him, and Windu dies trying to arrest him, without Anakin's intervention. Windu realises Palpatine's power way too late. After all Darth Maul was supposed to be trained and be better than the Jedis, said so Palpatine.
(2) Palpatine moves in against the Jedis and has them killed without Anakin's involvement. Anakin is on the bed side of his dying wife while Palpatine and his Forces trap and murder the unsuspecting Jedis one at a time.
(3) After the Jedis are dispatched, and with Anakin not knowning the exact details, Palpatine appears and saves Padme from death, telling a story to Anakin and coercing him to join him (join Palpatine and not the Dark Side of the Force especially).
That would be half the film, what I have seen so far.