Better than the other 2

Rating: 4/10 (4 June 2005)

Its better than the previous 2 but is still pants. Push all 3 films together, scrap the awful pod racing, frog people, and dinosaur riding and you have one film which would have been OK. Lucas has a ham-fisted writing style and his scripts are awkward and force his actors to deliver lines which exhude cheese. His film direction still rocks but seems to be cluttered with techno rubbish, the opening shot is so forced and CGI'd that it looks like a video game. There is no great spectacle, just a mash of images which never really achieve the "great" impression on the viewer that a New Hope and Empire Stikes Back achieved.
Better than the other 2 and worth watching in the cinema but nowhere near the brilliance of the first 2.