nice video game ...

Rating: 5/10 (21 June 2005)

I do not understand why so many people think that the film is better then the parts I and II. A bad film is still a bad film...
For me it is more a video game with brilliant graphics. Nice to see the graphics but when it comes to what a film makes a film it has it shortfalls.
The dialogs are strange and stupid. The acting is mostly bad. There are many logical mistakes. The change of the character Anakin into Darth Vader is still a mystery since it is not credible. One basic assumption of the film appears that (nearly) all characters are thought of being stupid. Why is windu storming without much backup to get Darth Sidious? Why is Anakin not smart enough to see the lies of Sidious? He has been taught for years about the dark side but is without much hesitation accepting it. Why is a Padme so weak? she is the leader of a nation, older then Anakin and appeared stronger in the first movie. Why is General Grievious coughing and limping when he is mostly a droid (and very healthy when it comes to the fight).
It is really sad. The Star Wars Saga has deserved much better. It would have been great to see a much greater complexity and a more enlightening plot. It would have been better when George Lucas would have invested more in story writing - there are many talented SF writers out there! - and directing (and a better actor selection process for the main character).