Perfect with one flaw

Rating: 10/10 (28 June 2005)

What film does not have flaws, right? Yet, what movie is more fun to be critical on???
First, so you can feel where I am with this film - it is better than Return Of The Jedi. Sentimental favorites aren't always created 20 years ago. Revenge of the Sith had everything you could have hoped for. This had more action than anything I have seen in years.
My problem is the scene where the platform falls on top of Obi-Wan's legs. When a platform falls on you, or shall we say pins you for this example - YOU ARE NOT GETTING UP. Not only are you not getting up, you are not running 10 minutes later. I can almost see them rebuilding his stomach down as they do with arms and such throughout the Star Wars legacy, but c'mon! Trust me, I know it's fantasy, but they at least acknowledge if a arm gets cut off and needs to be repaired.
Now, most people have a complex over the amount of time it took Anni to turn to the dark side. Although it was a sluggish transition, I respect the amount of time the film was considering what needed to be covered.
This was a work of art.