C'mon, you can't seriously believe this is a top 250 film!?

Rating: 5/10 (20 May 2005)

Granted it's better than I and II, but the acting is still execrable apart from Ian McDiarmid and the plot is still bordering on the childish.
In saying that, the CGI is jaw dropping stuff if laid on a bit too thick at times - after the n-billionth light sabre fight, frankly I was getting bored. And why Lucas had to 'personalise' the droids with emotions and voices - especially those reminiscent of camp 6 years olds on helium, I'll never know!
Don't get me wrong, there were some good scenes and I particularly enjoyed 'order 66' and the overall darkness of the film - but these just weren't a patch on the originals...
I'd give it a 5/10 - 6 at a push, but 8+ you have to be kidding!