Good, not great

Rating: 4/10 (23 May 2005)

I'm baffled by the number of people here who are calling this the greatest movie ever. 49% game this movie a 10. I know this might be hard for hard-core Star Wars fans to do, but try to get a grip on reality.
This movie was good, but not great. I recommend that people see this one in a theater because the highlight is the special effects which will be lost on the small screen. If this one has to rest on story alone, a rational person will notice it falls somewhat flat.
With that said, it was interesting to see the creation of Darth Vadar. Also, for someone who enjoyed the 1st one (the real first one from the 1970s) as much as I did it was nice to see how everything came to be.
On second thought, I don't care. You want to this this was the best movie ever, go ahead.