George Lucas screwed this one up

Rating: 4/10 (19 May 2005)

What was good: -Anakin on fire -Anakin's charred remains -Most of the dialog -The slaughtering of the Jedi -Most of the end -The appearance of the Tantive IV -Grand Moff Tarkin -Opening space battle (eccentric, but interesting) -When Anakin pulls a lightsaber on the children
What sucked: -Vader's "NooooOOOOoooOOOooo!" (It was God awful.) -Palpatine's constant weird noises -The lizard bird thing that Obi-Wan rides -General Grievous (The way he walked, the way he talked, his stupid coughing.) -Some of the dialog -R2-D2 versus the battle droids in the beginning -The fact that most of the action was mostly CG, which makes it grossly unexciting