Good, but...

Rating: 8/10 (4 August 2005)

I'm a fan, not a die hard fan, but a fan, this final piece in the Star Wars Saga is in my point of view the best, not for the special effects, yet they are incredible, finally George Lucas made a story, that ties all the lose ends together created by The Phantom Menance and keeps the film moving (a problem in the other 5, sometimes.
But Hayden Christensen fails big time, a good looking actor but expressing his feelings, a no no. He is empty, take the scene where he kneels before the Emperor and all the scenes with his wife Padmé, no emotion on his face to be seen, except in the Anakin versus Obi-Wan fight. Sorry but it ruins the emotional side of the movie. Lucky for me, Ian McDarmid(Palpatine), Natalie Portman(Padmé - even the very small role she got this time) and Ewan McGregor(Obi-Wan)are fabulous!
I love this film also for another reason, it's for adults, nicely dark, very good fights and no stupid parades at the end. A movie for my sci-fi collection.