I'm a bit disappointed

Rating: 8/10 (24 May 2005)

I was so excited about this film that I even was reading up on it six months ago. But after this film, I can't believe how let down I was. Yes this movie has a dark undertone, which makes Anakin's choices that much more paramount. This is the focus of this film.
The special effects and color are amazing! It really pushes what Peter Jackson did for Lord of the Rings. But where Lucas failed was in the presentation and salesmanship of this film. He had some of the greatest actors today on set. I have a high level of respect for Ewan, Samuel L, and Ian. But the plot was pushed, the acting was choppy and cheesy, and it felt more surreal than any of the previous 5 movies. I was disappointed from the Dooku saberfight on. That is not to say that there were not peaks. Certainly after order 66 was laid into motion, I felt so sad for the falling Jedi. Also, the fate of Anakin was quite moving as we see the origin of the mask. But there no deep reflection and very little meaning.
My conclusions can only be that this film is a must see, a must buy, but I'm disappointed that Lucas didn't deliver a high quality product this time. What I'm looking for in this film is spectacular graphics balanced with deep meaning and witty dialogue. The last two weren't there.