I give it less credit than most people do.

Rating: 7/10 (26 November 2009)

Even though this is the best of the sequels, it can never top anything off the original trilogy, which surprises me when I hear some people say this is the best.
Still some stiff acting Not enough force to drive Anakin's completion to the dark side.
Even the ending I have to be critical about due to the fact that CGI ruined it. Also, it was too quick of an ending. It should have been eloquently elongated only a few more minutes instead of "Ok, so this happens to that person and this happens to them and that's how that happened--"
Some extra Vader scenes in action would have been awesome.
Vader's "NOOO!" moment made me cringe; it looked like Frankenstein or something.
The rest: all good, and don't need to talk about it.