Criticize this movie, I must !!!

Rating: 6/10 (19 May 2005)

Although I have never criticized the prequels like the way which somebody did, I believe that this time I must.
Let's start with the good ones. I've nothing to say about the special effects. They are brilliant, better than LOTR or any other movies that have been done so far. Action scenes are also good, the wars on different planets, Anakin-Dooku duel, Obi Wan - Grevious duel and the beginning of the Anakin-Obi Wan duel are the most impressive, as well as Yoda Sidious fight.
On the other hand, Windu-Sidious fight, which I wanted to see the most, is a scandal, terribly acted and a dull scene, which forced me most to give this movie a "6" instead of "8". Acting was also dull, especially, Ewan has disappointed me this time. However, Hayden's performance is better when it's been compared to the episode 2. Besides, the movie is too short, the story of the Anakin Skywalker's turn to the dark side, should have taken more time, but it occurs in a jiffy. And the director George Lucas !!! I am very upset to said that but I think he should have never directed this movie... It could be Peter Jackson or Steven Spielberg but not him.
All in all, the movie is not the best nor the worst, it is above the average nevertheless still far from what it should be.