i think it's great,but...

Rating: 9/10 (14 November 2005)

I LOVE Starwars, and i was waiting just like millions i think for this finale, and i loved it and saw it twice in Theatres.but what is wrong with Dialogue?,George Lucas written episode V i presume, and it was great !!, the dialog's could've been much better if Reviewd.
the effects are of course spectacular,just putting you in the star wars world you imagined and lived in since 1977,and the acting is great i think ,especially from Hayden Christensen, he just got better than episode II, and of course Ian McDiarmid , this movie is his, and all the cast was good, i especially liked general grievous,he is charismatic and i wished that Gary Oldman did the Voice-over.
the transformation to Lord Vader came in haste i think and the "NOOOOO" yell was bad,it may have been a better moment,but the transformation from the emperor to Lord Sidious was surprising to me and i liked it along with the end of master Windu and Anakin's treason, i loved this part overall since "Padme's ruminations" to the "tragedy of the Jedi temple".
i am waiting for the TV series from Mr. Lucas, this man is a genius and he created a world and names and characters that put his name in the history of cinema.