totally objective

Rating: 9/10 (24 May 2005)

this film was amazing. the best of the six in my opinion. anyone who criticizes the dialogue should stop and think for a second. these films have never been about the dialogue. it's always been a little hokey from the beginning. what's so great is the story, the action, and the special effects. i loved the original three. episode 1 had some good moments. overall i thought episode 2 was a waste. lucas ended the saga on a high note. episode 3 delivered big time. the battles were of the best in the series. the special effects were still breathtaking. don't dwell on the dialogue. the story came full circle. he was as thorough as two and a half hours would allow. i loved it and i think time will show that this is going to be a classic.