Why does everyone say this is a bad movie?

Rating: 9/10 (14 November 2005)

I just finished watching Star Wars Episode 3, and oh my god it was amazing!!! Seriously guys? What are you all on about?? This movie was amazing why do you knock it??? I admit it had its major flaws and very very laughable moments......
The young lings??? This is another one of George Lucas's bad attempts at scripting! Couldn't he had come up with a better name for the young Jedis?? Younglings???? ER.......OK!
Hayden Kristen (however you spell his name) his acting has improved so much more than the second movie....still very wooden but gave a good performance in my opinion! Plus I felt that Ewan McGregor tried a lot better in one too as he made it clear he didn't wanna be in these movies in the previous one!
Yoda still looked bad as a CGI character but he still kicked major @$$!
Oh and how could I forget.........."NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO!!" Oh no indeed! Again Lucas bad attempts at scripting with this rather bad and terribly cheesy Darth Vader moment!
And just to add one more flaw....Lucas cannot write love scenes!
ANAKIN: You're Beautiful PADMAY: That's because I'm in love ANAKIN: No....I'm in love with you!
WTF??? :S
But above all else....I loved this movie, It had so much excitement and I was drawn in from beginning to end! The build up to the ending where Anakin turns to the dark side was fantastic and I really loved the way that everything that was good in the first two movies all turned upside down and this movie was so dark, just the way I wanted it to be!
I really wanna know what you guys meant by this being a bad movie?? I personally believe it's because people compare it too much to the first three movies, obviously you cannot compare them as they are classics and these are new movies with brand new effects, I try to think of these as new movies and I throughly enjoyed each one!