best of the Pre, but still sick (spoiler)

Rating: 3/10 (20 May 2005)

Anakin literally changing from saying "What have I done?" when killing a jedi to "Yes let's kill of them" in a single scene. Is the emperor like hardcore mind control that we don't know about? He says "I can't kill him, it's against THE WAY." "Yes do it." "Oh, OK." And why does he try to learn the dark side to save padme? I thought anger led to the dark side, not compassion and love! And why does Padme know basically that the republic is evil from the beginning and yet she can't understand Ani when he says "I'm lost." One thing definitely did improve though: dialogue between characters was phenomenal (for a prequel of course) It's funny, when you watch Lucas' earlier films like Star Wars ( the only of the three originals that he actually wrote and directed) and THX 1138 you see what appears to be a veteran film maker who entertains and is well developed in direction style despite them being only his first few ventures.
But when you watch the new films, you find a filthy rich filmmaker seemingly obsessed with using CG and creating very cliché and unrealistic dialogue. Example: The emp says "I want you to do a service for me." Anikan says quickly "WHAT? I don't understand!!" hold on a minute to let me explain a moment! Jeez, you jedis aren't good people people.
But whatever the flop, let's not forget that George brought us Star Wars in the first place, despite F ing it up big time with his own pocket book agenda. But hell, I'd rather have a half good star wars and half bad star wars than no Jedi at all.