Rises the same hight as giants as LOTR and The Matrix

Rating: 10/10 (22 May 2005)

Spoiler!! SPOILER!! SPOILER!!
I just saw this movie after months of painful waiting. I have seen all the other movies and I be a big Science-Fiction addict.
I don't know why you people keep busting up this movie just because the dialog kind of sucked! The political intrigue, the complexity of the whole plot and that feeling of "it all came crashing down" when the ambush started just made me forget about this world and almost shed a tear for the republic.
No matter how cheesy the dialog is, any movie that has success in transmitting a sentiment to the viewer, be it sad or happy, is a GOOD movie, and this one sure did.
It's dark and surreal.
When it ended, everyone left and I almost forgot to stand up from the chair, I was speechless and still in the movie :-)
I kept mumbling "I've never seen anything like this... how can this movie exist?".
Think past these minor flaws that only amateurs take into consideration and praise this movie for it's Asimov worthy idea and sentiment.
I watched as the movie slowly turned from the lame atmosphere of the last two prequels to the dark and merciful atmosphere of the early episodes, until it finally bridged this gap with the creation of the death star in the end.
10/10... i'm still trying to decide if this is the BEST movie EVER...