Just as bad as 1 and 2

Rating: 4/10 (17 October 2005)

I think that most people enjoyed this movie just because it was the tying-together point for the entire star wars saga. The acting was cardboardish at best; the scenes with Padme and Anakin were just ridiculous. However, I don't believe that the problem lies with the actors, they are all actually quite good; its their lines that are terrible. The script writer should lose his job before he ruins any other movies. The movie's special effects were of course top-notch, but they lack the sense of space combat realism (yes I know that's an oxymoron) that the first 3 movies had.
Here be a spoiler: Also, aren't the Jedi supposed to protect citizens and do good, etc? I'm pretty sure that Anakin and Obi-Wan crash landed an enormous space ship halfway onto the spaceport, knocked over the control tower and probably killed many people in the process. Obi-Wan then quips something like "Well, another safe landing!" Whats up with that? That's not the jedi way, and things like this take away immensely from the movie. All in all, this movie, and Episodes I and II, completely lack the intrigue and general greatness of the original 3. By God I could have done a better job...