Oh my god. It's full of flaws.

Rating: 3/10 (29 December 2004)

I queued up to see this. I was excited. When those words started scrolling upwards and the score started thumping, I felt I *might* be in for a treat. Only *might* because I'd seen Phantom Menace. Within half an hour I knew I'd been cheated again. No character development, no script, nothing but special effects. The 'love' between young Darth & Portman is appalling ..'you're not like sand, sand is coarse..' etc, his transition to evil simply not credible. How sad to see something die like this; Star Wars used to be fun. When I look at the films I saw as a kid, there's no comparison. Who writes this stuff? I don't think I'll bother with Episode III at the cinema. Of course there will be a tidal wave of hype; you must see it at the cinema, it's better than the last two and so on, but it won't make any impression on me. You can fool a man twice Lucas, but not three times.