Not good but not terrrible

Rating: 6/10 (1 July 2020)

There are some good elements in the story.
The romance, Natalie Portman is great, Hayden Christensen is OK if you admit his IQ lowers by half when in the presence of Padme, which is not that unrealistic.
Storywise the Jedi are incredibly stupid throughout, they don't see the forest for the tree. Some things are ridiculous like the "execution" drama on Geonosis. The appearance of the clones is very good and the battle with the Federation Army is OK.
Actionwise, there are some very good sequences that are entertaining like the shapeshifter in the beginning and the very good sequence between Obi-Wan and Jango Fett. Others are not so convincing like the factory and the arena showdown on Geonosis. The Jedi vs Dooku battle could have been better as well, although it was nice to see Master Yoda show his stuff.
Overall this movie needs a script editor. Too many cringe elements like the banter between R2D2 and C3PO that falls flat every time.
It is not too bad and it works well at entertaiment. Given the budget and the class of the actors, I was expecting so much more.