A little disappointing, but would still recommend seeing it.

Rating: 7/10 (20 May 2002)

As a huge Star Wars fan, I was happy to see the movie just to see the characters progress from the last movie and see the "history" of the previous Star Wars films finally being played out. However, as I have seen better come from George Lucas, I was disappointed in the movie as a whole.
In an article about the film, one writer stated that the obsession Skywalker has for Amidala is driven by the fact that a day hasn't gone by that he hasn't thought about her. I thought this was an interpretation of the drama. Instead, that's exactly what Anakin says: "Obi-wan, I have been thinking of her every day since I met her." And things like that pepper the entire screenplay - they tell instead of show. I believe the movie was too talkative. Things can be said without actually saying them and that gave a very immature flavor to the entire movie for me.
As it has been said many times in reviews and articles, the best part of the movie is Master Yoda's lightsaber duel. THAT alone makes the movie worth seeing...that along with the wonderful visual effects and artistry of the movie.
As a Star Wars fan, it's impossible for me NOT to purchase this movie for my collection when it comes out on video/DVD. I can't have an incomplete collection. I will say that Episode I: The Phantom Menace was a better movie...and I've yet to see any of the Star Wars films top "The Empire Strikes Back". Perhaps Lucas should get his writing partner from THAT to give this final movie (Episode III) the grand exit this series needs.
Signed, A devoted, but truthful fan