Uneven and often dramatically flat, but provides enough intriguing developments and action to entertain

Rating: 7/10 (26 May 2015)

Summer blockbusters are experiencing a decline in second installments. Since 2008, they haven't been able to surpass or even meet the quality of their predecessors, the only exception being "The Winter Soldier". It's a shame because superior sequels were once practically a guarantee, a trend that even stretches back to the 1990's with "Aliens" and "Terminator 2". The second Star Wars prequel falls into that category. Though not as well received as "Star Trek: Into Darkness" or "Age of Ultron", this is (in terms of visuals, story and action), a more dynamic and satisfying motion picture than either of those.
Despite several contrivances and flags, "Episode II" manages to engage thanks to a steady stream of intriguing developments and an acceptable balance of story elements. The double subplot structure echoes "Episode V" and, unlike the first prequel, the truly significant stuff doesn't feel like byproducts of some relatively minor conflict. Contributions to Skywalker's journey and the transition of the old system to the Empire are at the forefront, and when everything converges to the beginning of the Clone Wars it really feels as if the saga has taken a great leap forward. Political content remains, but these are largely part of the backdrop and give the impression of a republic on the verge of civil war.
The (necessary) romance subplot has elicited the most ire, some of which is justified. Truth be told, it's not terrible, just largely hit-and-miss. Yes, the dialogue is cliché riddled and the progression in attraction doesn't feel natural, but this isn't the nadir of movie romances. There are some appreciable interactions, such as the dinner scene and when she takes control of the situation right before they set off to help Obi-Wan. My favorite moment between them is a quick exchange in the arena that recalls an earlier conversation. It's a shame really; these two work surprisingly well when fighting alongside each other (even Han and Leia never really showed this type of synergy). John Williams' theme for this subplot is noteworthy because, honestly, I think it's better than the love theme from "Episode V". It's more elegant and an overall more pleasant piece of music.
The cast is, thankfully, given more to work with, and if one isn't too concerned with who they are, there's at least enough to care about what they do. Skywalker is popularly reviled due to his impulsiveness and complaints, but I don't find it to be as much of an issue. A couple of scenes push the peevishness, but time is taken to show that he's not without merit. He commends the jedi leaders at least once, saves Obi-Wan's life and, most notably, shows great remorse for his actions at the Tusken camp. It is here that the personal failings that ultimately lead to his conversion first come to light. Natalie Portman seems more confident in the role of Padme, as the character shows an increase in determination and proactivity, even more capability in a fight. Obi-Wan mostly serves as a guide for the audience, but during his investigations you really get the feeling that he's the workhorse of the group, which grants him some esteem. Christopher Lee is under-appreciated as Count Dooku, whose confidence is evident in every scene. He's a convincingly capable enemy, one surprisingly good with words, though it's lamentable that we don't learn more about his fall. From the encounters with Windu and Yoda, it's clear that much is left unexplored. The CG are a delight, particularly the Kaminoans and the ever-rugged Watto in a surprisingly sentimental scene, while the CG Yoda boasts a strong presence throughout, similar to a grizzled master warrior.
The typical "Star Wars" high standard for visual effects once more elevates the experience, with an overall look that can best be described as refreshing. In addition to the polished, gloomy Kamino and John Carter/termite-inspired Geonosis, we are treated to new perspectives of older settings. Coruscant is given more life than before (as well as some noir-like visuals that complement the mystery aspect of the narrative), Naboo's scenery is expanded and Tatooine has a darker side displayed. Unfortunately, (with the exception of McGregor) Lucas failed to extract appropriate reactions from the cast, yielding the common complaint of a disconnect between the performers and settings. Even so, ambition is evident and half measures scarce; you'd be surprised how many of those backdrops are not CG (the Geonosian Arena, for instance).
The final 40 minute action sequence is well worth the wait, possibly the best conceived battle in the series at the time, building to a massive conflict that gives the full impression of warfare. Sporting hundreds of lightsaber wielding jedi, 3 creatures, the imposing super battle droids and a host of new war vehicles, there is no shortage of memorable images. Those missile firing hail-fire droids and turbo- laser platforms, in particular, are outstanding..
One thing I will freely admit is that the final lightsaber duel makes little sense past a certain point. Yet, it's still an engaging sequence; innovation and sheer progression in intensity can go a long way. I'm not of the opinion that involving Yoda in swordfighting undermines his contributions to the mythos. His comments on size pertain not to general matters, but to its lack of bearing on the capacity to perform feats with the Force. The fact that he is able to perform such difficult maneuvers that outclass his colleagues', despite pertinent physical limitations, reaffirms that notion; it further shows his mastery of the Force.
Though "Episode II" has its faults (forced romance, stilted performances, villains with untapped potential), its contributions to the saga make it a worthy addition. If you're looking for deep, compelling personalities and relationships, you'll be sorely disappointed. But, for those who appreciate the entertainment value brought by impressive sights, energetic action sequences and a momentous story, this one gets a hearty recommendation.