Not Lucas's best!

Rating: 4/10 (8 January 2006)

This movie was pretty good except for a few details, which I shall list: 1)The fact that Lucas wrote this script is horrifying. What is even more mind boggling is that he wrote all of the Original Star Wars scripts, which were really good. Something went wrong. 2) Hayden Christiansen ruined the movie for me, him and the disgusting dialogue. I thought his character was FAR too whiny. His acting also needs some work to say the least. And finally 3) The special effects controlled the movie and overshadowed the story line. George Lucas needs to take a lesson from Peter Jackson on how to not let CGI control your film. I hope Lucas also knows that the only reason that his new Star Wars films made any money or got any recognition, was because of the old ones. When Episode I came out, everyone went to see it because they remembered how good the old ones were. That is the same case with II and III. Everyone was hoping that maybe, just maybe, THIS new one might be good. Alexander Smith