The Best

Rating: 10/10 (22 July 1999)

Phantom Menace is the most interesting, thought provoking, and entertaining films ever to grace the screen. It's unfortunate that people can't enjoy it for what it's worth, instead of constantly comparing it to the original trilogy. As much as i like the original trilogy, this movie is definitely on a different level. The screenplay, special effects, acting, cinematography- these are all better in Phantom Menace than any of the originals. Furthermore, Lucas does a wonderful job of setting up what's to come in the future(i.e the rise of the empire and the downfall of Anakin). Every single scene in this movie has a definitive purpose, and only after a few viewings can a person decipher this. The plot works so seamlessly it is amazing.
I think people hate the movie because they are too stupid too understand it. In the first trilogy, Lucas got criticized for making his movies too simple. Now he has put together a wonderfully complex story, and yet now in ironic fashion the viewers want a simpler story. They don't have the attention span for a movie this complex, and they take out this anger by bashing this movie. I am sorry folks, but Lucas didn't make this movie for idiots. He made it for people who like to think, true fans who are willing to analyze films.
And for those people bashing Jar Jar, I think you are pathetic. It is clear Lucas made this character to appeal to young people, and he needed this because this plot was too complex for the average child(or even adult unfortunately) to understand.
George, if you are reading this, I want to thank you personally for creating such a thought-provoking, entertaining and imaginative film. I know that many people are ripping down your film, but don't worry(I don't think you are). 10 years from now people will look back at this film in awe, not only for its amazing special effects but for its masterful storytelling and thought-provoking ideas. I have seen this movie 7 times and loved it every time, and I plan to see it at least 3 more times. People love to tear successful people down because they are jealous. Well, you are truly a genius, in every sense of the word. I have an incredible amount of respect for you. Just keep sticking to your roots and everything will turn out fine.