Weak on story, strong on hard core FX

Rating: 8/10 (24 May 1999)

An orgy of over-the-top special effects is the only reason to see this film if you're over the age of thirteen. Every other element in the film left me disappointed. The juvenile comedy, confusing story, poorly developed characters, and just plain goofiness (e.g. I kept waiting for Sam Jackson to go into some Pulp Fiction inspired lecture about the tyranny of men) really left me stunned. The much talked about Jar Jar character was as annoying and silly as any adult can possibly imagine.
This film simply didn't have the magic and wonder of the first Star Wars, or even the second or third. I truly hope Mr. Lucas will take note for the follow ups and give the adults in the audience something to really get excited about, besides the special effects.