A mixed bag

Rating: Null/10 (17 January 2000)

Yes, the character of Jar Jar was botched. True, Jake Lloyd's acting left something to be desired. Sure, the movie lacked the flair and drama of the original trilogy. And definitely, the film sorely missed what Harrison Ford brought to Episodes 4-6, a dose of down-to-earth humor and grit.
Yet I can't quite call this movie unwatchable. It is a visual treat throughout, particularly during the Pod Race and climactic sword battle. And I thought that Neeson, McGregor and Portman all gave fine performances, especially since they didn't have the best script to work with. (Also, it was nice to see Frank Oz do Yoda again, as only he can.)
Perhaps this movie will have an effect not unlike that of the critically panned "Star Trek: The Motion Picture," which resulted in a better second film. Perhaps Lucas and Co. will rebound with a livelier flick, closer in quality to "A New Hope," "The Empire Strikes Back" and "Return Of The Jedi." With the news that Jar Jar will return for Episode 2, I can't say I'm too optimistic. But with the right Anakin, it could be done.