This is Star Trek alright. It's excellent. Could be sublime though.

Rating: 9/10 (6 June 2013)

Let me start by saying that I love Star Trek and Science Fiction in general. I re-watched all Star Trek movies more times than I would care to admit. I know, or at least I'm convinced that I know, what Star Trek is about. I loved the Star Trek reboot, first in 2009 and now its sequel Into Darkness.
It's all there. The moral dilemma, the friendship theme, the human weakness, the human brilliance, the strong and emotional characters, the philosophical theme. Yes, even the battles, not found in abundance in all Star Trek movies but still an important part of the show, especially in some particular Star Trek movies. Only now, it has better effects and better production value in general.
There's verbatim dialog yes, but that's only known to us, the Trekkies, the people who know Star Trek inside out. And, I really enjoyed those moments. It feels good to be back home you know?
To the haters I say: I agree with some of your assessments, the film could have been even better, plot-wise, tech-wise. I agree. It could be sublime, it's only great to excellent. But, what about the excellent acting performances? What to say to those special effects? What to say to the twists and turns, and the surprises that keep you glued to the screen not knowing for sure what will happen?
This is an extremely fun and entertaining movie. And, it's Star Trek alright. Is it more action-packed and has it more special effects than the average Star Trek fan is used to? Yes. But, it makes sense for this movie in particular to be like that (some original movies were also more action-packed than others).
So, give yourself a favor and go watch this movie in the theaters. You will not regret it. Of course, if you are not willing to accept a breath of fresh air, and you're unwilling to make room in your mind to accept this reboot (or any reboot), because it will never be as good as the originals... Well, that's really not the point I have to say. The point, I think, is to go to the movies, have fun, relate to the characters and learn a few things, or at least take something with you that makes you think.
Highly recommended. 9/10
Certified by long time Star Trek fan.