Give the franchise back to Frakes and Berman

Rating: 7/10 (25 September 2013)

First off, die hard fan, every episode of every series, and every movie. I was excited when Abrams got the 2009 reboot and he definitely brought some very positive things to the franchise. The cast is outstanding with most of the character development tweaks being a positive thing. The problem is being so overly focused on character development that it kills the plot. This was clearly evident in 2009 and didn't get too much better here. It certainly seemed like every time they wrote themselves into a hole, some character made a dramatic emotional plea to another character. It's a plot device severely overused in the franchise which hopefully does not appear in the 3rd movie.
2 movies don't really make a trend but I have little faith a 3rd movie with Abrams directing will be a significant improvement from where we are. In order to do better, Frakes and Berman should take an already outstanding cast, set and special effects team, and give them the plot they deserve.
I also sincerely hope they don't use this movie as a kill to the eugenics thread. I know it wasn't completely wrapped up but there's still plenty to explore. They only hit the tip of the iceberg in Enterprise Season 4 and there's so much to do. Mayhaps for the 4th movie in the reboot franchise? Certainly doesn't have to be the next movie, but it's a good thread to follow.
I don't mean this as a slant against Abrams but he's done what he can do and, really, Star Wars needs all the love he can give. I'm still very excited for the sequel trilogy and have every confidence he will give it the majesty it deserves.