Lots of arguing criticism

Rating: 10/10 (10 September 2009)

I'm so great fan of SCI FI films & of course STAR TREK is my number one as series, or as films. I believe that after Rondenberry died, other directors & producers have the right to create their concept about the Federation, either in respect of the time sequence & the main philosophy of the original creator, or without them. A nice film is based on an acceptable script, on professional acting, on a respectable budget, etc. Personally I'd accept & be fond of a Star Trek film or series, even not in absolute terms with the sequence, or the philosophy of the original concept, as long as it fulfills the above characteristics. I liked the film even if I keep my reservations too about some scenes, some actions like the one mentioned in others comments saying that in the environment of a Starfleet, no officer would ever drop out of a spaceship a fellow officer just because they had a serious agreement. There are ways to solve even the greater disagreement. But lets not stand on this kind of endless discussions about details or scenes, or time lines... The film was great & the quality also.