We got the daredevil, but where's the explorer?

Rating: 7/10 (11 May 2009)

I enjoyed the movie, dubious black holes, plot holes, and all. But... It was a bit relentless about checking off the to-do list of references (in jokes, mostly) and quotations. Most of the variations in character competencies, motivations, and relationships were justified and interesting for future reference.
But even allowing for the requirements of the plot, this Kirk is pretty much a stock action hero with no hint of the curiosity that made him interesting in his previous incarnation (and was a far more sympathetic reason than common bar brawls for him to get into trouble).
And I haven't seen such improbable promotions since the Rebel Alliance made Han Solo a general in Return of the Jedi.