nice fast Action, but not a Star Trek

Rating: 3/10 (8 May 2013)

This film is a beautiful fast action film. It contains everything that is needed to create a good action movie: fast action scenes, a lot of things getting destroyed, and a nice fresh cast.
I would have loved this film, and i still love him, for being a nice action movie, a Star Wars rip off. But nothing more. It's something you watch and thats it. Nothing to remember, nothing to rely fall in love with.
Star Trek was never an action movie based franchise, but an purely science-fiction based franchise. That's what the old Trekkies love: The discussion of technology, the moral aspects of the action.
J.J. Abrams has thrown these base ingredients of Star Trek over board and applied only the name to a low class space-fantasy-action production. Not even the quality of the acting can cover this.
Even if the moral aspect can't be as prominent in an movie as in an television series, it was always there.
Beside that, Abrams uses "Technology" that is in total contradiction to current science: black holes can't be used to travel through time, they would consume everything that comes near; a matter, capable of creating a black hole out of one drop would create a black hole as soon as produced.
Last but not least is to consider, that the film lives a lot from it's glorious heritage and the established fandom, but not of it's own. We tend to overlook a lot of flaws in the film in favor for it's inspiring young characters. If Abrams (and CBS/Paramount) wants to hold the fandom and to hold the value of the Star Trek Brand, they have to get back into an long lasting Star Trek we know from the TNG series and the movie era.