An Absolute Triumph -- They just have to be careful, moving forward...

Rating: 10/10 (16 May 2009)

The writing in this film is fantastic. Though some standard science fiction plot devices are used, what they say about this film is true. It can appeal to Trekies and non-Trekies alike, even though being one does help you understand the nuances of the characters, especially Kirk and Spock. The main accomplishment of the writers is their simplicity. Sure, the plot may look familiar, but it is fluidly and BELIEVABLY executed. Keeping Trekkie-level complexity out of the plot not only expands the viewer base, but also allowed the writers to focus on delightfully placed humor and character development that is consistent in the eyes of Trekies, and intriguing in the eyes of newcomers.
This is what kept the film from being the disaster the pessimists and purists may have believed it to be when it was first in production. JJ Abrams has my respect. He brought in a cast that all did a splendid job capturing the essence of the 1960's, but also acknowledged the needs and wants of twenty-first century audiences. It was EXTREMELY bold melding Spock's Vulcan and human aspects, but he found the right balance and that was important for both creating and maintaining the hold on both demographics of viewers. That's the new century twist needed in movie making these days. Surprise the old dogs, excite the new!
There are small holes and unnecessary elements of the storyline, but the beautiful thing about EVEN the flaws is that the Trekies will naturally forgive some, and general audiences will forgive the others because they are flaws both sides are respectively accustomed to seeing. You will know these when you see them.
Bottom line, this is phenomenal film making and I hope we see more! Let's just hope once they get past their peak, they will recognize it and stop!