It DEFINITELY depends...

Rating: 9/10 (1 August 2005)

Well, firstly, this had to be more popular when it first came out, like most movies. It's not meant to be serious, it's simply lighthearted and shouldn't be treated otherwise. Secondly, you have to realize that the Spice Girls aren't serious. Should they make a movie, it wouldn't be anything depressing or even anything that made you think. It is most pleasant to watch on a sleepover with your best friends and dance around lipsynching the words. You must be a Spice Girls fan to watch this movie. So it definitely depends on what you like, etc. So maybe it would have been more popular in 1996-1997, when the Girls first came out.
9/10--Because I'M a Spice Girls fan. ;-)