Reply to Rick Brands comments

Rating: 9/10 (1 April 2009)

your comment: "The storyline's a wash - to name just one inconsistency, as Salman Rushdie pointed out: from Bombay to the Taj Mahal by jumping a train? Really???" ----------------------------------------------- Ummm, that is a very unimaginative and boneheaded comment. They also didn't fall off the train 7 years old, then dust themselves off to discover their were 8 years older. The scene transitions them to their teenage years. They could've just as well easily fallen off a truck. I just watched that scene and you don't see them fall off the train as teenagers. It was just a nice transition from childhood to their teenage years.