good but not great

Rating: 1/10 (6 January 2009)

This is a good film...but not great.Many people find this film great,because 90% people are so emotional.The writing and editing is great along side it's unique idea.But I think if in the end Jamal lost every bit of money it will be a better finish and make this film a all time great.The things I dis-like most is ...
1)After wining 2 million Jamal waited in the station but no one around him(no media..no journalist...no passenger).Previously(after winning 1 million) it shows he is so popular that every person in the road recognize him.
2)After wining 1 million he is captured by the police because host of this show wants it.But after winning 2 million host don't call police.
3)Actual cause of his(Jamal) coming to this show is he wants to be noticed by Latika.So, before the last question he succeed to his mission.So I think it will be more appropriate to show he win nothing(money)..but everything(meet Latika again) like a Millionaire.
4)Most of all half of dialog of this film is in Hindi and other half in English...WHY?It should be completely Hindi or completely English.Last year's film "Môme, La" is completely in french and that makes it so good.
5)Most of all if you think slightly you will realize that ...Jamal came from slum where nobody care about him and later part of his life same thing continue..suddenly because he win 1 million people cares about him...so if he lost money...then the station portion(sitting all alone and waiting for Latika) will be a master stroke.
6)Jamal got entry in "Who Wants to be a Millionaire" from the call center.But it does not allow him to be in the hot seat.Because after somebody got the chance in phone he has to attend a question(which has all 4 write answer and you have to arrange it in Ascending Order and Descending Order)to be in the hot seat.But it should be shown in the film because about this the film is made.so it should be complete from beginning to end . 7)Most of all "Who Wants to be a Millionaire" never shown live..not in India and not in America too. My point is for only enjoyment it's a wonderful film..but it not gonna get Oscar.Because it has magic..but lack of logic.