disturbing, although well edited...

Rating: 5/10 (20 March 2006)

I found that this was a pretty good adaptation as its editing style and art direction made the movie feel like it worked as a comic.
however, while watching it, i was annoyed more and more by the type of violence. I'm not a conservative person- and i can get along with all of the violence and lewdness in movies (Kill Bill and American Psycho are two of my favorites) - however shouldn't there be point to the graphic nature of a movie. The violence acted as fluff to a movie lacking in a cohesive plot and good acting (sorry, alexis bledel- you need to stick to the WB).
This movie never got passed it's shock value stage with me. It's disgusting nature and bad plot outweighed the time spent on masterful editing and interesting effects.