Now, this is what I call an Art film with a capital 'A'

Rating: 9/10 (28 March 2007)

I will be very blunt in my initial comment on this film: It is a Scandal that this film has been totally overlooked by the Academy. If ever there was a movie more deserving of an Oscar for the cinematography, make up, set decoration and special effects than Sin City, then I haven't seen it!
The "feel" of the film is absolutely extraordinary, the style incomparable, never seen before, totally out of this world (which is exactly the point). I don't give a 9 lightly, and if the screenplay had been up to par with the rest, this would have been a pure 10/10. This motion picture is pure cinematic art at it's best.
My compliments to all involved!