Not as good as the comic.

Rating: 8/10 (24 January 2006)

The movie made from Mr Millers comics did capture the essence of the Sin City comics. The stories are interesting to see on the silver screen, and the way the world is portrayed is very exciting. In Mr Millers world, there are no shades of gray, just shades of black. Actors did a great job, and I especially enjoyed Mr deToros part.
The movie is very good. It is not every day you see something like this. But still... the stories were better on paper, and the beautiful pictures, that the movie too catches, work much much better with real stills. The richness that Mr Miller has achieved in his comics, is hidden between the pictures, and it is really hard not to compare the genius of the comics to the movie. And in this comparison the movie is left to a pale second place.