An overall great movie

Rating: 8/10 (26 November 2005)

When I heard they were making a sin city movie i was interested to say the least. the last comic book i read was the last spectacular spider man. I had no idea who Frank Miller was. Now that I have seen sin city I want to read the books. this movie is pure art, absolutely beautiful and i am not generally a fan of black and white movies but they pulled it off so well.I was amazed at the level of detail and how great the writing was. there was a lot of think- talking in the movie which made me realize how little talking you need in a movie to make it amazing. when the DVD release came out i bought it first day. my only complaint is that the DVD release did not come with a commentary by frank miller or the other directors. and the movie can be a little disturbing for some people but i loved it 10 out of 10!!! this is one of the best comic book to movie translations I have ever seen.