Original made film with idea?

Rating: 5/10 (19 June 2005)

Colours, actors & music are in this film very good. What else needs a good film? A good plot with idea!
The plot. I think comics are not a good base for a movie. Hollywood have made already a lot of them: Spiderman, Hulk.. and yet Sin City. None was good. There are 3 main heroes in this film & all of them, independent of each other, kill other people for their love. But what kind of love is it!? Playing with love and violence the film awakes different feelings: admiration, sadness, excitement but also disgust.
The idea. To show that even in the sin city there is some kind of love & feelings? The strange one. I have not felt after film, as though I have understood something new or useful. I have had a feeling, as thought I have watched 2 hours a decadent painting, a brutal one, with no hope for the people depicted in.
Does such pictures make our life better? Probably the authors & Tarantino think so, but every spectator is to have its own point of view, weather it is worth seeing & on this way supporting its producing.
The art without moral & ethic does not deserve to exist.