"unfilm" movie and mix of two media - but the wrong way

Rating: 6/10 (17 September 2005)

I really don't know if it's a mistake from Rodriguez, who couldn't tell a story in right way, or pedant Frank Miller, bad screenwriter (for example: Robocop 2 and 3), who wants an adaptation word from a word and comics picture to a same movie picture, but effect is interesting experiment and mix of two medias --- in a wrong way... Sin City is so silly, so manner (and over hyped) and schizophrenic (colour of the blood), and what's important - not a noir or neonoir! Noir movies have cynical main character, voice-over which tells what happens in the twisted story, but never says, what character thinks in a way of Sin City, and game of light and shadow was was never accidental. Some actors overplay (Rourke, Rutger), "underplay" (Del Toro, Owen), was funny in emotional scene (Alba, Dawson), or just totally out (Wood and Madsen)... "Sin City - City without oar live", how somebody said, has last 5 minutes of the film which aren't from any of the Frank Miller's book, but that sequence destroys all the atmosphere with a Mobil phone and medical machines, and it's bad pointed and timed... Movie wasn't have a temp or even rhythm, just static camera and circus music, bloody scene are so over stylized it's funny (maybe it was be funny?), but Sin City isn't glorification of violence. Sin City is just a wrap, nothing under it.
P.S. I apologize for my English, but I'm from Czech Republic.