Just saw it, I didn't hate it...

Rating: 7/10 (22 April 2006)

There was just a lot of parts I didn't like - mainly the scenes containing Sean Bean. I also didn't like a certain costume choice - I know the cop in Silent Hill wore leather pants too, but still.
That said it really did feel like the game. The sets were amazingly true to the game, as if lifted from its software, and Pyramid Head was friggin' awesome. So I recommend it for fans of it.
As for others, I recommend it as well if you can look past the bad stuff, instead of the usual jump scares, there are some true horror moments in this film and a lot of cool things as well that could easily elevate this into a cult movie. Overall, I give it a straight B.