ending of silent hill

Rating: Null/10 (27 August 2006)

hi, just a question really, iv seen the movie and am a big fan of the game the only thing that puzzles me is the ending of the film. Did rose and Sharon die when they crashed the car at the beginning or did they stay trapped in the realm of silent hill? iv discussed this with my family and friends to see what they think, mum thinks they died in the crash and thats how they could't go home. but i think alesha or Sharon didn't really want them to leave so have been kept in a different realm instead of going back to the dads real world. really just wondered what anyone thought or if anyone actually knew, if so would you be able to comment back with your suggestion or ideas?