Fun and smart

Rating: 8/10 (3 January 2010)

I knew right away that I wanted to watch this. Ritchie has a unique style, and while I would not have considered the idea of him using that approach to this franchise, I am immensely happy that someone did. This is very different from what we're used to, which has little to do with Sir Arthur Conan Doyle's books(read the FAQ), and it hits the nail on the head for the core of his stories. Adding a gritty tone, his playing around with the speed of shots(and using it to greater effect than ever before in his films, I might add), and some exciting action/adventure, Guy has reinvented Sherlock, and without losing the essentials. The plot is brilliant, with plenty of twists. It will keep you guessing, and the ending is tremendously satisfying. The script is in general impeccable, with *hilarious* British verbal comedy(and the accents sound right, as well), and well-written, thoroughly developed and credible characters and relationships. Every acting performance is spot-on. Downey Jr. was the perfect choice, as was Law. McAdams is sensual, and gives a marvelous performance. I am thrilled to see Mark Strong, who impressed me beyond words in Body of Lies, getting a lead role in such a big movie, and I hope his career will continue to soar. The pace is amazing, and in spite of being fast, it doesn't overwhelm and you can follow it all, including the complex deductions. Editing and cinematography are simply excellent. The whole thing is beautifully shot, Victorian London looks *gorgeous*. This has a rather high production value, with sets, costumes, etc. all being stunningly done. The score is a tad unusual, and works well. There is continuous violence(I'd call it brutal, but I guess it was trimmed just enough to not be?), a little suggestive material and several bits of disturbing content. I recommend this to everyone who enjoys mysteries and/or Holmes, and who can live with the lack of the deerstalker and Callabash pipe. 8/10