Best family comedy since Mrs. Doubtfire

Rating: 10/10 (11 October 2003)

This is the most fun I have had at a movie all year. I wasn't alone -- everyone was laughing throughout and a few even applauded at the end. If you are willing to suspend belief long enough to allow that Black's character might be desperate enough to try something like this, and then pull it off (for a while at least), then the rest of the plot is even plausible.
It's fresh and funny and easy to follow. My eight year old loved it. Other than a few mild curses and adult situations, there isn't much objectionable for families.
Black did a good job as the lovable loser, and although he looked out of place at times, I can't imagine anyone else in that role. But it's the kids who steal the show. They were all good actors and made believable musicians and they get some of the best lines. My son was even inspired to practice piano when we got home.
There are strong messages about teamwork (the film was careful to show all kids filling their roles) and working toward your dreams, and that it's good sometimes just to have fun. The kids were occasionally encouraged towards precociousness but they never got truly rebellious.
Highly recommended for young and old.