Great plot but.....

Rating: 8/10 (4 June 2005)

This is a hell of a plot. One of the few genius ..most genuine ideas that still exist in the world. Acting is perfect. I have this weak point towards Shawnee Smith and I think her short role was legendary as usual. Photography is great. No cheap thrills of the "Scream type". The problem is the same that I felt after seeing "Identity". The ending is too contrived .. too odd.. less credible than the whole movie. I think the makers of these movies try to outwit this silly talkative know-it-all guy sitting among the audience; by making the most unexpected ending. This blows the whole logic of the movie.. I have million questions about things I couldn't accept comfortably; but I can't ask any here because they r real spoilers. Anyway, this is one of the best 5 horror movies I saw in the last ten years, and I highly recommend it.