Negative criticism undeserved

Rating: 10/10 (10 February 1999)

I'm so sick and tired of reading people's criticism about the last battle. Have you ever heard the simple truth, that defending territory is easier than conquering it? It's absolutely true in all facets of life. It's no different in this case. Even when the Americans prevailed in the end, it wasn't Hanks and crew that delivered the decisive blow. It was the P-51 tankbuster airplane.
This movie is classic from start to finish. You can't walk away unaffected.
I also feel the criticism saying the bookend cemetery scenes was unnecessary is crap. I thought those scenes provided intro and the proper closure to the film.
I know that the first time I watched the movie I was wondering who the old man in the beginning was.
In the end, I feel this is one of, if not THE, best film I've ever seen. It's hard for me to understand the logic behind contrary beliefs.