Bad Taste. Great Production Value

Rating: 5/10 (23 January 2016)

I never write reviews but rarely do my opinions disagree with the IMDb top 250 so greatly so I wanted to explain myself.
Room has probably the highest production value of any movie. That being said, it primarily takes place in a shack and inside a house. That being said, it probably cost around 5 million to make. So high marks there. I must mention is has perfect acting. H Macy, Bree, that kid, everyone, congrats.
But in my opinion, perfect production value (script, camera, acting, directing, location, art dept, etc) does not mean the movie is perfect.
It's how the production value works together as a living entity. For instance, Star Wars has inconsistent production value, yet it is still watched today. That is because the bad and good production value come together and create an entity. A movie.
In Room, all the production value does not make a great movie. I leave the movie feeling empty and destroyed. I leave hating the cinema if that is the best cinema has to offer.
I digress, the movie needed to be told in a non linear way to make it more tasteful with about half of it being cut and replaced with something else. While I'm sure this is quite tasteful as a book, as a film, I don't want to see a women getting rapped in front of her son 8 times and nether should you.
This leads me to conclude that the academy, critics and many IMDb users are sociopaths. Or simply, nitpickers whom only care about production value.
The level of this dastardly accusation I have just come up with is proportional to the rate I disagree with critics, IMDb users, academy with a +/- 2 point buffer in regards to our respective ratings of this movie. I give this a 5.4.
This means I may be right in this conclusion:
Cinema is not safe.
But than again, it probably never was.