Solid Star Wars story done in an original way

Rating: 8/10 (17 December 2016)

I gave it an 8 because of the original presentation, the acting and character development. All the other 7 movies have the same presentation and this does not. This is far less kid like than episode 1, 2, 6, and even 7. It is much darker in its feel.
For me I like and cared for the characters, I herd differently by others. They seem real instead of supper hero smugness(the Jedi). We have characters that are flawed and with this we feel more connected to there struggle.
Some have said it was more like a war story, and it was. I would say this is "The Thin Red Line" to the other episodes "Saving private Ryan".
There is humor but its not presented like it would be in an after school special.
Things I did not like, the Music. I am sorry some of it worked but others I was wandering, OK how does that fit the mood of this scene. To be fair the scenes seem to jump a lot so it might be difficult for the composer to set a mood. The other thing I did not like were the CGI people, come on just use the new actors and the audience will accept it, don't be so George Lucas like.
The best part was this is just a story on its own and I wish they would do more of these. Also, it doesn't have to be a big screen movie, some have mentioned putting the Bane Trilogy on HBO, Showtime, or Netflix as a 10 part-er, and that would be great just add more violence, sex, and nudity and it would fit write in.