the best on this movie is Darth Vader

Rating: 1/10 (7 October 2018)

This movie wants to appear plausible but in vain.
Problems are the structure of the movie in general, and the usual succession of events too fast to make the characters reliable, furthermore there are too much apparent stupid choices, such as:
1) the imperial pilot traitor has long hair and beard;
2) the protagonist becomes the lead of resistance since the second meeting of rebellion;
3) the imperial regime could finish the Death Star but needs the help of a rebel scientist who makes the death star faulty. It's obvious;
4) the appearance of the rebel soldiers infiltrated is not plausible (they appear as rebels): "cutting both beard and the hair so to appear as an imperial soldier". As I said too fast events to make the movie plausible.
5) the movie is too much linked to the past narrative structure to be original - the viewer recognize this weakness so to be annoyed from it.
Another big flaw regards the possibility to introduce the original deleted scenes during the capture of the rebel cargo by the Imperial star destroyer when Luke observes the light in the sky of the fight as well as the dialogue between Luke and Biggs (you can see it on youtube) which would have enhanced the past events matching well between the Rogue One and A New Hope episodes in a wonder way.
I save only the final battle in the space although the absurd believer-fighter of rebellion who is not shot by imperial soldiers just because he repeats a stupid litany.
These reasons make both the storytelling and the directing mediocre as well, persuading me that by now Star Wars franchise is able only to give nausea to an illusory hope.