Perhaps my favorite star wars movie

Rating: 9/10 (19 December 2016)

I am surprised this movie does not have a higher rating, and by some of the mixed reviews. For starters, I consider myself a common Star Wars fan. I grew up with Ep 4-6 and have watched all of the movies more than a few times. I don't go to ComiCon or dress up in cosplay, but I appreciate the fantasy value behind the movies, as well as the acting, directing, and character development. And the action scenes and the struggle between good vs. evil is a big plus. Rogue One is arguably my favorite star wars movie. I was sorely disappointed in Episode 7 – too much "kid" and Hollywood appeal, too much of JJ Abram's fingerprints on it, and not enough individuality and too predictable. I could write a long critique on The Force Awakens, but perhaps another time. What Rogue One did for me and made me feel after leaving the theater is what I wished Ep. 7 had done. The movie was paced well (a bit too fast in the beginning though) and kept you focused on one scene to the next. The characters were all solid and played their roles close to perfection. There were some scenes/dialogue I thought would be corny, but I ended up appreciating them because I was empathetic and attached that much to the characters. Many scenes were genuine, the plot line was consistent and delivered a smooth transition between Ep. 3 and 4, and the action scenes were probably one of the most entertaining I've seen in the whole series. There was a great balance between ground battle scenes vs. in space, and it was never too overbearing where you were wondering when it would end. And there were some nice, pleasant cameos from older characters that were timed perfectly. The movie was unique in the sense that it was edgier than the other movies. You could see a darker side (no pun intended) of the rebel alliance. And, there was no real "love story" that has all but become too cliché and predictable. The director, Gareth Edwards, deserves a lot of credit. The cast does as well. The movie ended with me clapping and excited about the direction the saga is heading in and looking forward to future movies, something Ep. 7 failed to do. I think this movie would appeal most to my generation, the ones who grew up with Ep 4-6. I don't think I would recommend this movie to kids younger than 6 as there were some violent and dark scenes. Rogue One stands on its own and should be recognized as one of the better Star Wars movies.