Rockstar is one of the example of editorial disaster !

Rating: 1/10 (18 November 2011)

Plot, cast, storyline, music, songs everything great. but directors/editors are just under what dilemma made this movie, nobody can understand? Why our BOLLY people looks so obsessed with foreign location and European mentality? There is no sense as where to put what song? no connection between storyline and songs.
There was lot lot opportunity to make this movie as one of the long remembered blockbuster.
The questions one would ask him/her self and director would be? 1. What pain did Ranbir really had that lead him to sing painful/rebellious songs? 2. What the bloody hell was he missting in his life? He had Heer whenever wherever and whatever way he wanted? 3. A sheer absence of great platonic love.
4. Background score at certain level is just nonsense. no connection of words with situation.
5. What society did wrong with him that lead him to sing SADDA HAQ? Which HAQ was he asking for? 6. He seemed to became rockstar because of press reporters only.
7. What kind of message/lesson did he receive at Hajrat Nijamuddin.
First 45 minutes great. Ranbir falling in love with Heer(Nargis Fakri). Heer refuses his love because of family or pre-commitment and social reason (sanskriti etc). Ranbir performs at some unusual locations with refusal pain where stopped by society/system. Ranbir shares his modern ideology being NASTIK (not believing in GOD but in working for good cause). Taking up some issues also concerns current affairs corruption, women rights, youth rights, freedom etc. in his way of protesting? Turning youth by his songs in crowd then movement. Ranbir also experiencing some injustice in society by police, bureaucrat and then decide his way of performing and awareness of (arroganceGIRI). Heer dying of some disease and their family being reluctant to take fruitful action. Ranbir coming to rescue but stopped by Heer(unwillingly) and society. Ranbir falling down of pain pain then some miraculous happen people support help him come out and take some bold steps forward and saving her life. A global acceptance of his ideas can also be shown as there is international support.
I really had great expection from thie movie, but surely did failed. And all the songs of this movie are absolutely boring. And Atif Aslam was best if he would sing but Mohit chowhan is absolutely bogus. A fully bakwas movie. The worst movie I have ever seen in 10 long years...