problems with the medical aspects

Rating: Null/10 (16 April 2004)

First, let me say that this is an outstanding film and I have nothing but awesome to say about the actors performances...Ellen Burstyn and Jared Leno in particular being incredible.
I have a slight issue with the story. Being a doctor, I found it too much to accept the ending of this story. Also, I am hard pressed to believe that any licensed M.D. or D.O. would continue to prescribe amphetimines to a lady in this state (or even that they would contemplate starting one).
I have to mention that electroconvulsant therapy ("shock therapy") is painless when administered these days, it is given under sedation and has shown to be beneficial in cases of refractory depression (in treating amphetamine addiction, I do not know of any trials or studies). Ellen would feel no pain.
Secondly, Mr. Leto's arm would not be amputated for this infection, and even if it was, it would not be done with a circular saw. I am an orthopedic surgery resident, we do amputations all the time, but not in this cavalier method without regard to the major blood vessels and nerves.
Understandably, the movie is a bit more dramatic than reality would be.

'
.