Hard to choose was this good or not

Rating: 7/10 (30 October 2018)

As a big fan of movies, TV-series and games I liked the idea very much and the movie was made very well. Don't know about the book, still after 31 years haven't read a single book fully, so I cannot say how does this follow book, but that hasn't been problem for me in any movie.
Visual effects might have been the best I've yet to seen, might have to see 3D-version of this sometime.
But the biggest problem and almost the sole reason to ruin this movie was the lame acting by Sheridan, he is almost as bad as the worst acting ever by Bill Paxton in Aliens.