excellent movie!!!!!!

Rating: 7/10 (15 August 2009)

lets see the good things about the film, direction:- top class, the style of speeches and the perfect way and rather different way to tell a story. that is definitely a conduct of a good director. acting::- the best person to act in the best way was Aamir khan of course. plus the hero was Sidharth as well. Sharman Joshi and Kunal Kapoor are also brilliant in the movie.
technically the background score and the original score are also notable by the maestro A.R Rahman. it just never fail to swing your mind with patriotism.
however there are bad things in technicality as well.
first and for most there were goofs in middle which were not much noticed by many. a particular soundtrack which the musician had made did not fit in the screenplay. in simpler words it lacked good sound editing, and for few seconds there was a patriotic theme playing and the other at immediate effect it changed into some painful theme.
there were few(one or two) defects in editing as well. also the screenplay was to be blamed to make short scenes which sometimes increased the pace of the movie making it faster than the rest.
but as a story and acting and direction the movie is one of the best movies Bollywood has made.