Different beast

Rating: 9/10 (1 August 2012)

First of all you shouldn't compare this too much with the original Alien. It is actually a good thing that this is different. I wouldn't like it any other way. The fact that Mr. Damon Lindelof co-wrote the script might be an indicator that you're not going to get all the answers here. On the other hand, it was stated that this might be the beginning of a new trilogy or at least "saga".
Another thing that has been criticized is the scientific accuracy of the movie. But apart from the fact, that this is another society that might have other values, other standards than we know. Even if not, this is still a movie and things happen in here that are not "true" to what we know (especially in genre like Science Fiction!).
Onto the positive things. Visually this is more than stunning. Especially the beginning left me wide eyed. That was incredible. You may not like the movie as it is, but can't fault the technical achievements. I liked the acting too and I for once also liked the story. It isn't a genius concept, but it works more than nicely for the movie.
One of the most memorable scenes from "Alien" gets mirrored here and it has to be seen to be believed. It really has a similar impact. Another kind of beast this is indeed, but it still is a very great one