Not a Review, please don't report just an extension to michael-albertsen's post

Rating: 8/10 (1 July 2012)

CONCERNING THE "BEST" REVIEW Dear, michael-albertsen I really want to start out by mentioning I completely respect michael for his review and opinion and I i really don't like picking on his review but i feel like it's my duty to point out the holes in his review so that people don't get misguided.
I'm going to skip over the parts about the actual director and previous films because you probably know a lot more about that. I just want to comment a little bit on some of your reasons for the movie Prometheus being disappointing.
The first reasons you mentioned was her walking around with her muscles cut open like that, I understand why it would ridiculous, now, but the movie is based in the future and it wasn't regular anesthetic I think I remember taking a shot, we couldn't have possibly known how powerful or how improved they have become.
The second reason you mention that the alien species are more powerful than us and that they should just obviously bomb us, but if that's reasoning why do we now in days we still use bio warfare. They apparently have the same DNA as us or at least predating DNA according to the movie so I'm allowed to say THEY ARE HUMANS, HUMANS MAKE MISTAKES!
The next reason you mention holograms I really don't if your hating on it or not because to me I found cool and interesting.
About the characters that have are void of emotion etc. Etc. I believe that is an opinion, i felt they were great actors but yes like every single typical thriller movie the actors are supposed stupid or else the movie would end because no one would die if they were smart.
The next part you mention people willing to commit suicide by ramming the ship, they are willing commit suicide to save the planet first of all, they want to stay by the captain's side just for friendship and honor, if they would have left and stayed on planet they would have been stuck and most likely died anyways. When they say they needed stay because the captain "can't fly worth a damn" they were being sarcastic, joking around, not actually saying the truth hence the cursing to their superior officer, I find usual that friends find it normal to insult each other joking around.
The next point doesn't an argument I didn't understand what was wrong with it.' I see your reasoning in the part about the scientist yea that was a bit stupid.
A lot of the behavior in the movie is something normal people would do, if they were all super smart highly developed prefrontalcortex robots the movie would suck because the actors would be terrible. You also criticize the aliens in the movie I found the aliens pretty realistic and they tried to be as human as possible without being human I loved the aliens in this movie.
The robot who I think is an amazing actor too has the random motivations. In my opinion I think he was just curious and he wanted to know what would happen and he was fascinated by these aliens. Throughout the movie the characters mentions that he does not understand certain kind of emotions they maybe he could be a sociopath and not be able to sympathize and he doesn't care what happens to the humans. His motivations must have been selfish because he doesn't care about the other people's emotions because he can't understand them.
I also found the music pretty good, repetitive I believe but in some cases I like when the music repeats because it personalized that one theme.
I really think that you just took everything that is bad in the movie and replaced the entire movie with those things you disliked. You found three things you liked and added those like stars. I feel like you misunderstood the way normal people rate movies.
I agree with the whole "correct" interpretation and the emperor's new clothes thing, those are so true but I think this is just a giant opinion based of brief thought out complaints.
I also think if you would have thought out everything that annoyed you, you would have understood that the things that disappoint you are actually quiet understandable and the movie is still a great movie.
I have no idea why so many people found your comment so helpful I found it very misleading and it actually offends me how you rated this movie so low and the reason you did were illogical.
I hope that no one took your review as a warning and did not watch it, I know some people that say that this movie had bad reviews, I have a bad feeling it is because of this review but I won't hate only on you. The movie was great in many ways and I hope anyone interested actually watches it and doesn't drink the cool aid on reviews like yours.
It's not a review but I feel it's my duty to send this as a private message and a review on the movie just to clarify some points.