Above average sci-fi film in the Alien universe (but not making the alien the star)

Rating: 8/10 (10 June 2012)

I loved "Alien" and "Aliens", mainly because of the older, mature cast in different situations: The first Alien was a horror movie, while the second one was an action film.
That being said, when going to "Prometheus", know that it takes place in the universe as Alien/Aliens, but occurs many decades out, on a different planet, and touches on the actual alien itself in passing. I feel that too many viewers are expecting a direct Alien prequel, which it definitely it isn't. Also, I would classify this more as a sci-fi mystery/drama.
I actually appreciated this film a lot, as it touches on some pretty interesting concepts from "Bladerunner" (many reminiscent of Roy Batty's quest to the Tyrell Corporation). The most fascinating character in the film is easily David the android (played brilliantly by Michael Fassbender), whose cool and calculating demeanor are in some ways central to the emotive mirror in the second most fascinating character, Elizabeth Shaw (Noomi Rapace, who I thought was on par with Sigourney Weaver's Ripley).
Special effects and set designs were fantastic. There were many Giger elements in here, and the sets and landscapes were beautiful. I did not see the 3D version, but I may reconsider as there are some beautiful scenes that 3D would have accentuated well. If I had an issue, it would be that the tech shown appeared to be much more polished and advanced than what was seen in Alien/Aliens.
As for the story itself, I have seen many reviews ripping on the logic of some characters and their motives as well as some of the scenes. I think a lot of it can be explained away (there is a nice "FAQ" on this site on the forums explaining the many issues). If I did have a criticism, though, was that the movie was paced a little faster than I expected. I would have really liked hear more of the David/Elizabeth interactions, which would have brought a more intellectual bend to the movie. As for the Lindelof treatment of leaving things hang, I actually do appreciate it. At least that way, I know I am expecting a sequel (I am sure there will be one). I will, however, be let down if the sequel has nothing to do with path followed by the lead characters at the end of the film.
Overall, great film. I would recommend those who have not seen at least the first "Alien" to watch it for some (small) background. I also think that time(and quite possibly the sequels) will determine if it is a great film or not.