A brilliant rendition of a JA masterpiece

Rating: 10/10 (13 February 2006)

I went to see this movie without much expectation, as I was a big fan of the 1995 BBC series with Colin Firth. But my low expectations were overturned and I now consider it a much better depiction of the original novel than any of the previous adaptations.
I am in awe with what was achieved in only 2 hours. The characterisation and direction is so subtle, with multiple layers that repay repeated viewings. On first viewing I thought that many of the sub-plots were poorly done - Jane and Bingley, Charlotte and Mr Collins for example - but look at the background in the dancing scenes! There the many interactions of these characters show the development of their stories in a satisfying way. Even Elizabeth's relationship with her father is conveyed in a few shared glances of understanding and enjoyment - for example he starts baiting Mr Collins at the dinner table and she smoothly joins in - yes, strictly she is using lines that are Mr Bennets in the book, but it shows how much in tune father and daughter are, plus giving her a very witty, Lizzy-like observation to say.
In this version the Bennets are a real family, they interact naturally, even look similar and Joe Wright was very astute in developing some mannerisms that would be family traits. For example, their giggles had similar tones, and the use of the hand over the mouth, which Mr Bennet, Jane, Lizzy and Lydia all use. I also loved the fact that the actors were age-appropriate for the characters they were portraying - it made such a difference to how I perceive Lydia's antics (less knowing-slut and more young, giddy girl in love with the idea of love).
Another big plus for me was to see humanised Mrs Bennet, Mr Collins and even Lady Catherine - so different to the caricatures of the BBC version. This achieved a much better balance with the other characters - I could never believe that Alison Steadman could be the mother of Jane and Lizzy, or married to Mr Bennet!
Keira Knightley was a revelation, ably supported by a excellent cast, including Matthew Macfadyen (who has knocked Colin Firth from his pedestal).
The photography is brilliant as well, especially in the big dance scenes. The one-shots of the Netherfield Ball are some of the most effective I have seen. All in all, give this movie a chance, it draws you in and makes you feel you are a participant and not just a bystander.