Very enjoyable and passionate, but rapidly condensed

Rating: 8/10 (2 December 2005)

The cinematography and authentic time period setting were the two major selling points of the film. The movie was filmed so close to the action, so when combined with the commotion of day to day life, I felt as though I could slip right through the screen and into the late 1700's. There were some flaws to the time period, such as Bingley entering Jane's bedroom and what appeared to be water spouts in the Pemberley pond, but overall, a magnificent time period piece. Kiera Knightly was superb as Elizabeth - I had a difficult time finding fault with her on any front. Matthew MacFaden's Mr. Darcy was wonderful too. He was by far a different Mr. Darcy than Colin's Mr. Darcy - each of which were good in their own right, but it took me a little while to get over his sullen mood - he seemed more depressed than arrogant. He was still very desirable and his Mr. Darcy was much more passionate and interesting. The supporting cast were all delightful, but did think the director made a mistake by making Mr. Collins as sympathetic as he did. He was clearly not a sympathetic character in the novel, but the "alone at the ball with a pathetic flower in hand" scene elicited great sympathy. I did feel the screenplay was about as perfect as it could have been considering there are so many important sub plots that were essential to the story. Pride and Prejudice lovers would have tolerance (and desire) for a very long adaptation, so I was surprised they didn't make the movie a bit longer to prevent such a rushed story that bounced from one scene to the next. With so much dialog speeding by, it would be impossible for a person unfamiliar with the story to really understand the dynamics of what was going on. There was simply not enough communication between Mr. Darcy and Elizabeth either. I was left longing for more. I did love the movie for many reasons, but wished it was about 1/2 hour longer. and p.s. I loved the gushy ending us Americans were blessed to receive! It was perfect.