Mixed review

Rating: 6/10 (5 December 2005)

I understand what they were trying to do with this film, provide a more modern interpretation of Austen's famous book.
They fell short because they hacked Elizabeth's dialog. Instead of being witty, sharp and playful, she comes off as slightly shrewish and spoiled. Elizabeth's talent (which she shared with her creator, Jane Austen) is the ability to put the pompous down without them understanding what she was doing or saying . She also didn't take herself too seriously.
I disagree with the reviewer who said to chill, that only a little of the dialog was changed. Not so, a lot of the dialog was tampered with, for no good reason.
A few examples: Why did Lady Catherine make the comment about using the piano in the servants quarters to Charlotte instead of Elizabeth as it was written? It sets the tone for their relationship.
The first proposal scene. By removing so much of the dialog between Darcy and Elizabeth, the humor AND the outrage is dimmed. It is hard to appreciate why Elizabeth is so insulted, other than she is mad about his role in the Bingley/Jane affair.
The reunion at Pemberly. Why was she wandering around poking in doors, where was the housekeeper? By not allowing Darcy and Elizabeth to see each other face to face, the shock they both feel is lost. Where did the Gardners go? They play an important part in that scene. This is the first time Elizabeth sees a reformed Darcy being civil to her companions.
The final proposal scene. I have no problem with Elizabeth going out in her nightgown and running in to Darcy. However why the Fabio like slow mo of Darcy with the swelling music? I did like the affection between the Bennets. I thought the final scene with Mr. Bennet and Elizabeth was really nice. I also liked Mr. Collins.
MHO, this movie could have worked, it could have carved it's own place next to the Firth/Ehle version, but there are too many missteps.
I wouldn't recommend paying top dollar to see this, but you could do worse on a rainy day to rent the DVD.