Refreshing and accessible for those who know the story

Rating: 8/10 (3 February 2014)

As a lover of this story, both in its original book form and the 1995 BBC TV production which so faithfully stuck to the book, I initially found the many surprises contained in this film somewhat off-putting. But my reaction to a second viewing was decidedly positive. Love the pithy new lines in the script, the unique slants on the characters, and the whole thing feels more accessible and based in reality than the older production. My main complaint is that it does feel abbreviated; those unfamiliar with the story may even find it incoherent.
Several characters are substantially better cast and portrayed in this film than the 1995 production. Judi Dench has the presence we expect of Lady Catherine, and Rosamund Pike is drop-dead-gorgeous as we imagine Jane. In 1995, Julia Sawalha isn't silly enough as Lydia, and Mrs Bennett, Mr Collins and Miss Bingley are too over-the-top. Darcy and Elizabeth are great in both productions, although quite different. Firth's Darcy is handsome and aristocratic, but Macfayden's is younger, less aloof and less sure of himself. Ehle is a little too old as Elizabeth; Knightley is just right. I like both Mr Bennetts, but Sutherland brings some beautiful new nuances.