Bewitched, Body and Soul

Rating: 7/10 (14 November 2005)

Greetings again from the darkness. Get ready guys, the theater will be filled with fantastical women. The Cinderella story has always fascinated (tortured is probably more accurate) woman who think the handsome, rich prince will rescue them by falling in love at a glance and begging them to live in his giant castle. This is so much more romantic and efficient than actually getting to know someone! That said, Jane Austen was a master of creating the love story. Her dialog was light years ahead of its time. First, lovers of her books must understand that you will probably be disappointed by comparing the book to the movie. Two hours is a short time to cram in the details of subtlety of Ms. Austen's writing. Secondly, casting is key and this film surprises.
Keira Knightley was selected (amidst protests from dedicates of the novel). Many know Knightley from her breakout role in "Bend it like Beckham" and the few of us who saw her in this years' "Domino" couldn't help be surprised at her ability to handle the demanding role of Miss Elizabeth Bennett. No question, she has the eyes and smile to handle the first half of the film, but her effectiveness for the second half could be debated.
Relative unknown actor (at least in the U.S.) Matthew MacFadyen wins the lottery with his casting as Mr. Darcy. MM has the necessary ability to stand tall and not smile. He fails a bit in the romantic moments, but most women-viewers will have swallowed the hook and will not even notice.
Screen veterans Brenda Blethyn and Donald Sutherland (not really a Brit) are fine in their paternal roles and it is always nice to see the underused Jena Malone - even when cast as the slightly off center sister. And of course, no actor spews venom with the fierceness of Dame Judy Densch.
Not sure how Joe Wright was selected for the director spot on this film, but he does an admirable job of filming the beauty of the countryside and capturing the pageantry of the parties. Those not familiar with the times, may be a bit surprised at the lack of color in the clothes, but Mr. Wright went for accuracy.
Screen film versions of classical works will always disappoint those seeking perfection, but this one will definitely please the casual viewer and reader.