Once in a while, a Hollywood film wins

Rating: 8/10 (8 December 2003)

Make no mistake; this is a true Hollywood movie, through and through. But it's an entertaining one, to be sure. I was skeptical of its integrity when I learned it was "based" on the Disneyland ride, let alone a Disney film. But again, it does entertain from start to finish and despite moments of cheesy humor, it's serious enough to satisfy those seeking a more "real" approach. For the most part, it's historically correct. Thankfully, they used fictitious characters instead of tarnishing the reputations of true high sea swashbucklers such as Ed Teach (Blackbeard) and John Rackham (Calico Jack).
Depp pulls off a convincing character in Jack Sparrow, especially when you think he based the character on Keith Richards (mannerisms, hair and all). Rush also shines as Barbossa, while Bloom and Knightley fulfill their roles fittingly, though their performances are hardly outstanding. This has more to do with the script than their abilities. The cinematography and CG effects are outstanding and very convincing.
Another thing this film does pull off well is character development. They successfully illustrate 8-10 mainstay characters (lead and supporting) without bogging the story down or leaving things incomplete. This is quite rare in a film and I was pleased at how well it was pulled off.
All in all, if you haven't seen this film, do so. Though you may not be blown away, you should at least be entertained.