I would Recommend it

Rating: 6/10 (7 July 2006)

This was well made and well written with the exception of the plot. The movie was littered of sub-plots, and this wouldn't be a big deal if there was a strong tie between them, but this was lacking. The movie is better than Curse of the Black Pearl, but is darker. Also, if you enjoy long movies, this is for you.
The film is one of surprises and tense scenes, rather surprising from a Disney movie. The film is also rather dynamic, and quite expansive on the geography, which gives the feel for these pirates because you feel you've sailed the same waters that they have. The beauty of this is that, to some degree, you can choose a character to make a reference from and you still get the same experience from another character.
Overall, I would recommend it.