A lackluster sequel to a great movie..

Rating: 5/10 (7 July 2006)

I just can't, in good faith, rate this movie higher than 5/10. Maybe it's just because it's the sequel to one of the best movies ever. Maybe it's because it uses the same type of effects as the original. More likely, it's because the plot line doesn't really "go" anywhere.
The ending reminded me of The Empire Strikes Back. You know, the 2nd movie of the original Star Wars trilogy. It picked up from the first movie and, predictably, leaves open a few cliffhangers to lead into the 3rd movie. If you don't mind this type of thing, then read no further. If, however, you are like me and enjoy an 'ending' to a movie, this one will bother you.
The sets are beautiful, Knightley is gorgeous, and Depp and Bloom play the hero roles to near perfection. Dialogue is strong, but some of the side characters development is lacking. I won't put spoilers in here, but there are a few notable people in this movie, and we're never quite sure what their purpose is.
I do recommend you go see this movie if you enjoyed the original. I plan on seeing the final piece of the trilogy next year, so I felt obligated to see this one. I suppose it will prove to be a essential piece of the puzzle, so to speak, but right now I just feel deflated and unimpressed.