Fun is sacrificed for an overcomplicated plot

Rating: 6/10 (31 May 2007)

Pirates works best by putting the characters into random set pieces which are extremely fun to watch. Plot is strictly secondary to showcasing the talents of Johnny Depp and the rest of the cast. In this film the creators seemed to have lost sight of the main strength of their franchise, namely,it is fun to watch. They have attempted to create a mythology and give texture and history to their franchise. Unfortunately for them they are not dealing with Lord of the Rings but a film created from a theme park ride. Too much of the film is wasted by trying to give what is and should be a popcorn film depth through an intricate plot. I would much have preferred a few more cheap laughs rather than being insulted with such a ludicrous plot. In the rare moments when Pirates is allowed to be Pirates in the movie it still puts a smile on my face. However, in my opinion this film is not effective as the two earlier installments because it is strangled by an overcomplicated plot which is out of place for such a film.