Better then the second, but can't top the first

Rating: 7/10 (15 October 2007)

The first is ALWAYS the best. The second fell short for me. And the third, great. It was a confusing plot, no doubt. You have to pay close attention. But the action is great, the romance, humor, acting, everything is great. Why give it a nine? Well, the ending and the how much to threw into this movie.
In my opinion, they could have cut down on a few scenes and made it not so long. And the ending should have been different. Jack should have sailed away on the Black Pearl and Elizabeth should have /somehow/ gotten to be with Will.
But I saw what the writers did with Jack and Barbossa in the ending. Everything was set up just how it was in the beginning of the first movie. Catchy touch.
The acting, once again, superb. Captain Jack, my favorite, shined once again. You never become bored when watching him, or Johnny Depp.
Keira Knightley truly is growing in her acting. She's gorgeous and I hope she does well in the acting business. She has what it takes.
Orlando Bloom.. well, he could use some work. And a haircut. I enjoy Will Turner, but Orlando Bloom is on the bottom of the list.
Barbossa. I loved that he's back. One of the best villains around! Geoffry Rush is an amazing actor and fits perfectly into the cast.
Bill Nighy couldn't be better as Davy Jones. And the visual effects put into this character! Wow! Overall, this movie was great. But the first movie is still number on my list. I'm hoping there won't be a 4th. That would be too much.
Great job all the same. Pirates is amazing.