A Disappointment Movie of a Great Trilogy

Rating: 4/10 (25 May 2007)

Well I just watched the movie and here is my opinion about it, before this I was very excited, the movie looks really promising with all the pirate lords and etc etc, but honestly speaking, I was very disappointed with the storyline of the movie.
Storyline: There is a few mistakes that I found in the movie, the most controversy for me is the 9 Pirate lords, allow me to explain; Captain Jack is the original captain of the Black Pearl, so he is one of the 9 Pirate lords, but then Barbossa took over the Black Pearl and send Jack on a secluded island which makes Barbossa not one of the pirate lords. So why in the movie its stated as Barbossa and Jack as the pirate lords (Captain of each pirate ship)? To prove my point is that they captured Calypso using a item that each pirate lord owns, (Jack - his hair accessory, Barbossa - the guys falling eyeball), and this happens before the the Isle de Muerta incident (before the mutiny), see the mistake now?
Well I cant say that the ending sucks because people has their own opinions, but its kinda sad that Will and Eli is separated, and in the end, Will could be evil because he can only see Eli once every 10 years and mostly he can only see her for about 5 more times before she dies and after that he has no reason to live anymore? So its safe to speculate that Will could just be evil as Davy Jones.
Oh yeah and this movie has a lot of talking in the early part which makes it kinda boring, and I wish there is more fighting scene with captain Sao Feng instead of talking.
Action and funny scenes Well Pirate still maintain the jokes that they are well known in their series, and this movie is still great, they also have some new ideas in this movie which is very cool. The fighting? Awesome, I like almost all of the fighting scenes, but I was very disappointed that in the final battle where all the pirates are supposed to fight the East India Trading Company didn happen, and what you get is a scene where Black Pearl VS Davy Jones. I was like WTF, then why did they bother to bring the whole pirate armada if they will only fight with one ship, it will be much nicer if you can see the pirate lords fight with the EITC instead of watching the fight between Black Pearl and Davy Jones. LAME!!!.
Overall this movie is below my expectation and Its very sad to see the movie ended up this way.