Bad

Rating: 2/10 (2 June 2007)

They ruined Chow Yun Fat. He's a great actor. He can fake Kungfu. Why did they make him into a creepy freak with only 4 scenes? They showed every minority in the film as ugly and weird. The Chinese crew was mutinous, Sao-Feng was perverted, etc.
No one cared about the ponce guy, so why did they waste 30 seconds of CGI to film his explosion filled death?
Besides that the film looks like it was originally MUCH longer, but was cut down a lot to keep it under 2 hours. Lots of it didn't seem to make sense and everything seemed rushed, like Sao suspecting the girl of being Calypso then immediately being proved wrong by Barbossa makes it seem very pointless.