It was a good movie but somewhat overrated (possible spoilers)

Rating: 8/10 (28 January 2007)

I've heard of rave reviews before I went to see it and sort of know the theme of the movie. I also cautioned myself against high expectations before viewing it and it actually worked: I enjoyed more with somewhat less expectation.
First of all, I am absolutely a lover for fantasy movies and also appreciated the fact that the director tried to blend reality together with fantasy. I also liked the presentation of the fairy world as a darker, somewhat evil haven for the little girl. The storyline is decent. Color and camera work are good though nothing particularly spectacular.
However, this movie has quite a few clichÃ©d moments and kept reminding me of some other movies. Basically, I always knew what was coming and nothing really surprised me. I also found the fantasy part bear some resemblance to the animated movie " spirited away".
Another part I didn't find satisfying is the acting, or say the portrayal of certain characters. The captain for one is a bit too one dimensional. They actually don't have to repeatedly show the killing or torturing to prove the cruelty of the captain. I got the message the first time he shot one man. Sometimes, indirect portrayal would carry a more chilling effect. Ofelia's acting is somewhat lacking too. I know she's supposed to be a quiet, reserved girl in desperate need to escape. However, her acting is sort of bland. No matter what she heard, saw or realized, her expression never changed much and sometime came off as not caring about much at all. Even when her mom died, she never looked heart-broken. I don't wanna to be so picky about a child actor, but she actually has a very heavy role in the movie and I felt the plain acting took some power away from movie.
Overall, it was a good movie and I enjoyed it. But I felt the directing and acting could have kicked up a few more notches.