A wondrously grim fairy tale.

Rating: 8/10 (4 October 2009)

PAN'S LABYRINTH is a fairy tale, but it's not for kids. Ironically, the fairy tales that are for kids are as dark as this tale.
Spanish with English subtitles.
Set in the lush woodlands of 1944 Spain, during the waning of WWII, young bookworm Ofelia (Ivana Baquero) and her pregnant mother (Ariadna Gil) move into an army barracks with stepfather Captain Vidal (Sergi LÃ³pez), a ruthless fascist, bent on weeding out the last resistance fighters hiding out in the woods. Maribel VerdÃº is their maid, secretly aiding the resistance.
The marketing for PAN'S LABYRINTH is misleading, where they push the magical wonders. You won't find monsters appearing around every turn, rather, Guillermo del Toro writes and directs this very grim fairy tale as a drama, rooted in the real world of war - violent, painful and unforgiving. Ofelia escapes this world of constant suffering by becoming a part of the imaginative books she devours.
Unlike Jim Henson's LABYRINTH (1986) where a girl is transported to a magical world wholly separate from ours, the "magical" world in PAN'S LABYRINTH is so woven into the fabric of the real world that the transitions between the two are seamless and we don't get the sense of being transported to another dimension, so much as the magical world infiltrating into ours.
One night, a fairy leads Ofelia into the labyrinth behind the barracks, where she meets El Fauno - Pan - who informs her she is a long-lost princess of a subterranean world and can only return to her true father, the underworld king, by completing three tasks. It's the old Three Tasks gag again, in a modern movie about ancient occultism.
Doug Jones (HELLBOY's Abe Sapien) is Fauno, a faun unlike any you've ever seen; designed to look like he sprang from the living Earth, half-humanoid, half-goat, twigs and gnarled bark his skin. Although I think this is the first time I've heard a mythical beast speak Spanish. All those old Euro Sinbad tales and Italian Hercules movies always overdubbed English, so we take it for granted that - like STAR TREK - every un-human in every culture has to speak English for our convenience. It is almost jarring to hear Fauno use the language of the day-worker soliciting for odd jobs outside Home Depot. (Although he doesn't look as scary as some of them.) Doug Jones also plays The Pale Man, a gangrel creature who presides over an uneaten banquet, who has to insert eyes into his hands to see.
The gore in PAN'S LABYRINTH is an organic part of its violent reality and comes at us gruesome and shocking; a doctor saws off a man's leg - without anesthetic!; there are point-blank executions; Maribel VerdÃº never gets to show off her magnificent figure under those frumpy maid skirts, but goes hog-wild with a kitchen knife; Captain Vidal tortures a prisoner with a hammer, before his own cheek is sliced open and he must stitch it together - in closeup!
Like every fairy tale - were it to be examined deeply - there is a disturbing resolution, as Ofelia tries to save her newborn baby brother and discovers that Fauno seeks to sacrifice him to the Labyrinth - the portal to the lower world is opened by the "blood of an innocent." The only fairy tale I can think of more gruesome is the King James Bible.
--Review by Poffy The Cucumber (for Poffy's Movie Mania).