Why should I love it?

Rating: 3/10 (21 March 2009)

I want to ask Richard LaGravenese, the director of this film a simple and straight question? What genre did he want to make in 'P.S I Love You'. Romance, Darma, Art-house or Bland Cinema. If Bland was his motive, then he sure has succeeded. 'P.S. I Love You' is as bland as it sounds. I mean, its a really good concept but unfortunately it turns out to a disappointment. Why drag a wafer-thin concept till you get exhausted? Why delivering unwanted scenes and why letting such a great idea go to waste. This film disappoints and how!
Lets go with the pluses first: The film's idea is beautiful, A guy who dies in the first ten minutes of the movie, continues to be is protagonist. The films first hr is commendable and interesting. First-rate performance by Hilary Swank. Gerard Butler's cameo is fantastic. Lisa Kudrow is hilarious. Others are also good.
Minuses: Why drag a wafer-thin concept? Why put the vacation track? What's Jeffery Dean Morgan's character? Why not adding Sex Scenes?
'P.S. I Love You' is a sheer disappointment. Thumbs Down!