Based on the superior Love Letter

Rating: 4/10 (22 December 2007)

Just because a film is labeled a "chick flick," it doesn't necessarily mean it's bad. But in the case of P.S. I Love You, we have past history to show how mediocre it is.
Actually, the film is based (and uncredited) on Shunji Iwai's touching Love Letter - the tale of a widow who receives letters beyond the grave from her husband. It's an unabashed tear-jerker, but has a simple, unstrained narrative with an engaging central character. It's been warmly reviewed in the IMDb, and is the winner of a dozen international awards.
P.S. I Love You has the indestructible Hilary Swank, but it's also terribly strained. The humor is dull, and its numerous sad moments can leave a viewer resentful. There are lots of outstanding women's films, some classics, but this isn't one of them.
And while you're at it, seek out Love Letter - you'll be surprised.