Turgidly overly sentimental and sickeningly cute.

Rating: 6/10 (11 July 2008)

Gerald Butler is charming enough, and the Million Dollar Baby, Hillary Swank has charisma to spare. Still this movie with all the acting talent on hand is a clunker of a romantic comedy. It's buck up and move on theme is over done with bad dialog to spare. Especially unfunny is how much the in-laws hated her, and how much her mother didn't like him I'm a guy who loves a well done chick flick. And this isn't one of them. My advice to all you nice women who are wanting to see something sentimental and sweet: watch "Return to Me" or "The Princess Bride" again instead. And for all you girls who love your boyfriend's and husbands consider letting them walk the dog instead. Let us off the hook, we watched Sex in the City with you and were happy, but this show really is for women only. P.S. i love you has it's heart in the right place, but goes on and on, and we wonder what was Harry Connick Jr thinking taking the part of such a loser?