Logan's Run was better.

Rating: 5/10 (20 January 2014)

The vast number of plot holes and predictable plot made the film fun in a way. Let's start with the holes. (Spoilers). The alien supercomputer has just two people that it lies to get a job done. So who built the fancy condo that Cruise lives in? Who makes all the stuff that they use? The food? The medical devices? The portable bike? If the supercomputer makes all this stuff, why not just make some kind of drone repairman out of its own repertoire? Next, why suck all the hydrogen out of Earth? Hydrogen is the most common element in the universe. There's plenty on nearby Jupiter that would be trivial to extract. Or even a nebula. Or just collect solar wind.
Aside from the superfluous need for the drone repairman and Earth water, let's consider the predictable plot. Earth wins. Yeah! The ending feels good, but hollow calories. Of course we know something is fishy from the beginning of the film based upon the secrecy. After all, what are they hiding that they need their memory wiped? This plot of turning Earthians against their own kind has been explored already in the The Outer Limits. We know he's not going to really take his wife to die. Morgan Freeman already said he wants to be there to help nuke the Tet.
Despite all of these flaws, it's good old fashioned space opera like Logan's Run. Well produced. But I think Logan's Run was more fun.