Flawed, but likeable

Rating: 8/10 (20 June 1999)

Like nearly all "romantic comedies, this one is somewhat flawed. Julia Roberts, for all her acting prowess, seems a tad flat--like she'd been drinking a bit too much decaf tea. Her character is incredibly subdued, albeit charming (most of the time). Hugh Grant's character is seems socially inept, a strange trait for a guy that handsome. One would think he'd have the entire city banging at his door.
The dialog between the two never gets down to a lot of the "real" nitty-gritty" things one would normally hear in a developing relationship (we never hear him ask HER if she is married or has a boyfriend), and they spend little time talking about things they have in common.
All of the characters, including the supporting cast, are imperfect, which I believe is a plus. It adds an element of realism to this sometimes fairy-tale-esque story.
Still, in spite of these flaws and a sometimes predictable plotline, I liked it. There was a nice ambiance to the film, and I especially enjoyed the seasonal transitions at the end of the movie when he's walking down the street. Nice touch.
Compared to the recent "You've Got Mail," this movie is less predictable, less "American", often more realistic, and generally funnier. You wouldn't want to make an entire meal of this movie, but it's still a tasty dessert!