a great showing for all those involved

Rating: Null/10 (29 April 2004)

Absorbing tale of three boyhood friends in working-class Boston, torn apart by a traumatic childhood incident, who are reunited as adults when one of them loses his teenage daughter to a brutal murder. One, now a cop, races to try and solve the murder while the other, still bearing deep emotional scars, gradually becomes a suspect. Gripping, poignant drama with shades of American tragedy, leisure and detailed pacing from director Eastwood that allows his actors to shine. Penn-as a grieving and vengeful father-is at the top of his game, while Robbins-as a long-suffering victim-matches him in a more brooding, nuanced portrayal. Both won Academy Awards for their exceptional performances, but they're surrounded by an outstanding cast. A powerful, ominous tale of friendship, family, and innocence lost. ***½