Everything comes together, perfectly

Rating: 9/10 (5 July 2004)

It's been awhile since such a powerful cast has been pulled together, with screen time split equally between them, to form one of the most impressively balanced films that I have ever seen. Sean Penn is very impressive as the dramatic father of a young woman was recently met by foul play. Penn's character has a checkered past, much like Penn does himself. I have always respected Penn as an actor but this performance is probably his best ever. Tim Robbins is perfect as the worn down Dave Boyle. Robbins may seem stale and emotionless to some in this part, but that was exactly what he was going for, as his character has those traits. Robbins may have even out done Penn, but as Penn was the lead, he received most credit. The investigating detective is meekly played by Kevin Bacon. Although Bacon does not shine in this film, he is good enough, and interacts well with his co-stars. The remaining supporters are nearly spotless in their roles, namely Fishburne, who portrays Bacon's partner. The only knocks against this film are its run-time, and its seemingly 'double' ending. This film raises the question of which is more important, good acting or good directing? Well, this film certainly has both and it's clever exciting edge clearly displays this fact.