Ever hear of something called "Once Upon A Time, In America?"

Rating: 10/10 (27 October 2003)

*Almost spoiler-free.*
It was the cinematic swan-song of Clint Eastwood's old mentor, Sergio Leone. Well, the modest ex-mayor of Carmel, California might disagree. But, I think "Mystic River" outdoes OUATIA! Sean Penn's reaction (as Jimmy), to the discovery of his daughter's body, is the most powerful one I've seen since Daniel J. Travanti played John Walsh, in the TV-movie "Adam." Kevin Bacon is equally convincing as the cop torn between the letter-of-the-law and old childhood friendship. And, Tim Robbins will probably be competing, against Robert Duvall, for that Best Supporting Actor Oscar. Definitely 5 stars!