The strongest American movie since American Beauty

Rating: 10/10 (15 October 2003)

Mr. Eastwood has made a film of true and honest art. A film that looks up to Shakespear and actually does him justice. The depth and emotion that is in each and every scene is remarkable. All the Performances are for the ages. Mr. Penn creates a man that is deeply flawed and yet totally human. Mr. Bacon digs into a man's soul that has dealt with guilt and loss. Mr. Robins provides a man that is a child in mind and an adult in actions that is never cartoonish or ironic. The amazing Mr. Guiry makes Brendon something for the ages, a teen that is not a illustration of a teen but rather a person that has complex emotions and emotional reactions (he should win the oscar, or at least get a nomination). Ms. Gay Harden never sinks to cliches for a single moment in her playing of a woman that can not trust the man she loves, yet still loves him. Ms. Linney brings to life a woman that is truely Lady Macbeth. The music, Editing, and camera work are all exceltent as well. Mr. Helgeland's screenplay is bound for oscar gold. Great job to all involved! This is a must see for any movie lover or average film patron in general.