Glitz Over Substance

Rating: 4/10 (8 December 2003)

As a "theatre geek", I was awfully disappointed with this film. Yet again, Baz Luhrmann's cinematography takes center stage, his fast-paced camera movements and bright flashy set design overshadowing his characters and story.
First, I must say I've never been a big fan of Baz. In my mind, his masterpiece was "Strictly Ballroom". There was a balance between visuals and story that made it a truly great movie. Then came "R+J". Shakespeare for the MTV teenage-set. While I admired the idea, I held no love for the finished product.
And the same could be said here. "Moulin Rouge!" is nothing more than a splashy, musical rendition of "The Lady of the Camillias". Most tragic is that while I adore Ewan and Nicole, I can't help but notice their lack of singing talent. And the same could be said for every other actor involved. However, I am relieved that the musical numbers consisted of shallow pop tunes. If I had to listen to Nicole Kidman attempt to sing the music of Porter, Kander & Ebb, or Sondheim, I'd be deaf.
For the sake of the "Movie Musical", I wanted this film to succeed. However, I was left feeling nothing but pity for the genre. So much so that I was prepared to loathe "Chicago" (definitely my favorite stage show) and was wonderfully surprised.
I really admire Luhrmann's attempt, however I think he's better off sticking to original material. If you want to see a great musical, watch "Singin' in the Rain" (essential) or "Cabaret". And if you enjoy the story of "Moulin Rouge!", watch "Camille". No one can beat Greta Garbo.