many medically flaw, does this indicate quality in production or deserving best picture of the year

Rating: 7/10 (4 March 2005)

I am an anesthesiologist. Many of the scenes in the movie are not medically logical . How can such sloppiness reflect excellence in production, directorship or even deserving best picture of the year? If the production people had spent anytime in a spine injury unit, they would discover the speech component is severely compromised on a ventilator. It is highly unkind to unplug the ventilator before rendering unconsciousness. Even my medically naive wife was shocked by such treatment. I hope no copy cat going to do euthanasia this way.Well researched production would be more deserving for the title of best picture of the year.