If only more directors of today had Gus Van Sant's courage and vision...

Rating: 9/10 (17 February 2009)

The story of Harvey Milk is one that very few are aware of, but it is arguably one of the most important and controversial stories in the recent History of the United States. Gus Van Sant successfully and competently brings the story of the first openly homosexual man elected to office, and does so without infusing any degree of pretension, hypocrisy, or melodrama (which would have been easy to do in a biopic of this nature). Indeed, viewers are treated to a smart, emotional, and historically-accurate portrayal of one of the most influential characters in the history of the Human Rights Movement. The story is supported by numerous historical/archival clips dealing with, and related to the key incidents of the story.
The ensemble is impeccably cast, with Sean Penn in perhaps his best bit of acting following MYSTIC RIVER. Again, Penn avoids the expected pretentiousness and melodrama that a role like this may entail, to excellent effect. The nomination for Best Lead Actor was well-warranted, and may very well result in a victory. Josh Brolin's nomination for Best Supporting Actor was equally well-warranted, as he does more in his expressions and mannerisms to portray his character's dilemmas and tribulations than many of today's actors can. Emile Hirsch and James Franco are equally impressive.
The screenplay (written directly for the screen), direction, and cinematography are quite excellent, and serve to make this technically one of the best films of 2008. It is no surprise that MILK was nominated for Best Picture, thought the controversial subject matter, coupled with a strong field may well prevent it from achieving ultimate victory. It is also my fear that IMDb ratings and box-office numbers will falter due to the raw subject matter.
9/10. 4 stars (out of 4). Will enter my Top 150 at 148. Unreservedly recommended.