Overrated (top ten of 2000 at best)

Rating: 1/10 (30 January 2006)

Would you stop trying to figure out every detail in the plot as if the director meant for it to be there. The story is meant to be ambiguous, and the fact that there are blatant plot loopholes makes the debate of trivial points meaningless. Top 25 movies of all time? Top Twenty-Five!!?? I mean, Goodfellas was good and all, but it had nothing close to a Guy Ritchie performance. Maybe if it added a few unnecessary camera tricks and some vapid dialogue, but.... Just because a storyline is edgy and somewhat original and makes you think for about 5 minutes (it was probably the first 5 minutes hardcore Memento fans ever used their brains), it does not mean that the movie is automatically deserving of Masterpiece status. The same people who think this movie is profound also love The Butterfly Effect "cause, like it brings up some cool ideas, bro".