This script carried this film

Rating: 9/10 (10 July 2005)

Hardly a single line out of place. Like Gene Roddenberry said about science fiction scripts - it is only workable if you ask the audience to believe ONLY one unbelievable thing. This movie sticks to that rule.
Given the initial supernatural premise, the script that it flowed from was logical, subtle, and neatly stitched, with great development of the characters' conflicts and harmonies.
Pitt is smooth and very well played/directed.
Claire Forlani reminds me of Kate Blanchett. I'm surprised she's not more famous. Her smiles and perfectly timed expressions were a visual treat.
I really like the way the question of whether 'she knew' was answered. "I wish you could have met my father".
Anyone who couldn't enjoy this film is missing something.