This movie does EXACTLY what it sets out to do

Rating: 8/10 (25 August 2009)

For all of those who mock the poor singing, the 'odd' casting, and so forth, you have to remember that all of these ingredients add up to a Movie that captures exactly what Mamma Mia is supposed to be about!
Who is the primary audience of this film? Women, Aged 40 - 60
Who likes to sing these songs, regardless of how they sound singing them? Everybody
What is the movie trying to do? A hint of nostalgia A good time - letting go and embracing self Reflecting on parenting
Look at the directing: It's designed to bring everybody in and be part of it, no matter what walk of life you're in.
Look at the writing: Almost no conflict! What is there is so minimal or goes nowhere. It's all feel-good, even some of the 'negative' moments. Comedy also abounds.
Look at the actors: Meryl Streep is a Mom, can pass for between 40 and 60, can sing decently enough, but not superb: She sounds like she could be your best friend. Pierce Brosnan: (Yes, cringe-worthy singing), but so what! Women in that age bracket LOVE him. Colin Firth: I reference a movie title that wraps up why he's here: Bridget Jones' Diary.
And by the end of this movie, you feel absolutely content. All the major players are matched up, everything is resolved, and everyone is happy and blessed! This movie's audience would not be able to HELP but to leave the theatre without feeling good.
I think it this movie is exactly what it is supposed to be and does exactly what it is supposed to do. And for that, I salute all involved!