I would drop one scene from this movie

Rating: Null/10 (20 March 2004)

I loved this movie. I thought it was a beautiful love story. I fail to understand though, the significance of the scene where Bill Murray's character has sex with the lounge singer.
Until this scene is presented we like him as a faithful husband and father who is somewhat smitten by the young and beautiful character played by Scarlet Johanson. After he sleeps with the singer, he is not only unfaithful to his wife and children but Scarlet's character is dismayed because she feels he picked being with the bar singer over being with her. So as the writer or Director of this movie I would have cut this scene. It did not add anything to the movie and made Bill Murray's character less likeable.
Most everything else about the movie was great. I did not particularly like the soundtrack but I guess much of the music, especially the Karaoke was meant to be bad.
I agree with most of the positive reviews of this movie.