Many great aspects, but Charlotte not believable

Rating: 6/10 (17 May 2004)

Sophia Coppola has shown much of her directing prowess in this movie, but I really feel her development of Charlotte (played by Scarlett Johansson) is lacking. There are many great interactions between Charlotte and Bob Harris (played by Bill Murray), but there aren't any times where Charlotte shows any other facet of her character besides her emptiness and sorrow. Her being that pitiful the entire time she's in Tokyo just makes her unbelievable to me. Real people are multi-faceted. Even when they're distraught or sad, or just feeling empty, they will have those up moments when their inner strength kicks in. Charlotte never displays this. Perhaps there are people out there in the world that are this weak. But I just don't believe it.
I wish I wasn't so bothered by the character development of Charlotte because there are some excellent aspects of this film. Many of the shots between Charlotte and Bob are perfectly crafted to convey their underlying connection. And Bob's character is developed well, as he comes across as a real person with multiple facets to his personality. Overall, I would still recommend this movie, especially as a rental. Just don't be surprised if you also notice there's something lacking.
6 out of 10.