Top notch action with a weak script

Rating: 7/10 (23 February 2014)

There is much to admire in Peter Bergs tribute to the men lost in the botched 2005 Operation Red Wings Military expedition but there is an overall feeling one gets also that Berg has himself to blame for failing to properly establish his 4 leading men beyond typical war film characitures and give the film an identity and audience affiliation that would of allowed the film to pack a much bigger emotional punch.
Lone Survivor starts things out in promising fashion with the opening montage of real life military training giving the audience insight into what these man endure to become elite soldiers. The subsequent segment at the Military base of the man gives off the sense also that we will be spending some quality time getting to know the man involved in the real life tragedy but it's merely a false pretense for once the operations starts all character growth is stunted in favor of typical war skirmishes despite them being unquestionably well staged.
Berg delivers world class direction of a roughly 40 minute barrage of frighteningly realistic action that while acting as edge of your seat, white knuckle filmmaking due to a disappearance of any character we truly know or care for it can only take the film so far. In the lead role as Marcus Luttrell Wahlberg gives one of his less charismatic turns with only Ben Foster making something worthwhile in an acting sense with his turn as Axe. When talking about Kitsch and Hirsch they equally don't get an opportunity to make much of there underwritten roles which is a strange thing considering the wealth of information that would of been made available to Berg upon research of these real life man and when reading about the films research time spent to do justice to them in the movie it would be considered a failure for the film in allowing us to not get a sense of who they were as there lost in a spray blood squibs and bullets.
Lathering on the patriotism thick and fast Lone Survivor is a impressive feat of filmmaking that is not allowed to truly shine thanks to its lacklustre script and cardboard characters. With more time spent on the script and developing these brave men into more than mere movie soldiers that movie would of been a sure fire war classic cut from the same cloth as films like Black Hawk Down and Platton. Special mention must also be paid to the stunt team on this film who on face value look to have endured some serious bruising on there work here.
3 and a half agonizing mountain side falls out of 5
For more movie reviews and opinions check out -
www.jordanandeddie.wordpress.com