Could have been better

Rating: 6/10 (18 June 2007)

Yes, it could have been better, with a director who knows how to handle rich material like this. Polanski's name was brought up by one reviewer, I'd mention Regis Wargnier too. Olivier Dahan has directed music videos and Crimson Rivers II among others, and I'd say he's out of his league here. The brothel scenes come off badly: confused action and bad camera-work abound. The grimy cafe scenes are no better, often you can't figure out who's doing what to whom.
When Piaf meets Raymond Asso, who tutors her on how to move and project her voice, things start to improve. The New York scenes are among the best: the set design and lighting really work and create the mood of Piaf's great love for Cerdan.
Marion Cotillard's performance has been praised by just about everybody on this board--she's really marvellous. Jean-Pierre Martins as Cerdan is excellent, so is Marc Barbe as Asso. Sylvie Testud as Simone Berteaut, a sponger as well as companion, does a great job.