I don't understand why people adore it

Rating: 2/10 (26 February 2008)

I really don't understand why people like this movie. I saw it 2 months ago and I was SO disappointed. Dahan should really go to school and learn how to write and how to edit a movie, it was awful and confusing to watch. I remember a documentary that I saw a long time ago about Piaf, it was so interesting, I was waiting the part of the film dealing with Marcel Cerdan (because it is THE reason why Piaf is so moving when she sang later "L'hymne à l'amour"), but mostly nothing about this relationship, in 10min it was done (the sequence when her agent come to say her Marcel is dead is ridiculous, while it should be a turning point of her life) What a shame!! And now Marion Cotillard won an Oscar... Well...It was an "oscar role" as we said here, because she accepted to be ugly in it while she is beautiful (remember Charlize Theron) so I knew she will won for that but please, stop it, NOTHING is moving in her interpretation!!!
Beautiful songs Bad script Bad editing
I really don't understand, and I'm French.