Not great, not terrible. Its neither a 1-Star movie, nor a 10 Star

Rating: 7/10 (26 November 2017)

First of all: Batman vs Superman was not the best start in the franchise, but it also wasn't as bad as many state. Its kinda trendy to hate on the movie, and i feel like the same happens for "Justice League". Both Movies are not excellent, like the dark knight (dc) or winter soldier (marvel), but they are both above average, while "Justice League" is the better of the two.

The Following contain SPOILERS -

The movie is entertaining. It lightens up the atmosphere or BvS a little, so there are some jokes in it mainly with Barry Allen/The Flash. And most of them a funny. But its still not as funny as most marvel movies. Its still dark and is a good contrast to for example "thor: ragnarok" which was more of a comedy with action scenes and not very serious.
Most characters work really well:
Batman: I still like Afflecs Batman. A lot of people hated on him in BvS because "he isn't acting like batman". But most of the people who do that just have no idea.. and there is a time in the comics where Batman is acting exactly like Afflecs Batman. People forget that this version of Batman is not like just in business like the Batman in the Nolan Trilogy. He is batman for 20 years. He saw his Sidekick in Robin killed by the joker and so on.. so its completely understandable that he got a little "fucked up" and more serious and darker.. His performance in justice league was good again. Nothing to criticize here.
Wonder Woman: She just works. She just looks stunning in every seen, and you cant turn your eyes away from her. Her fighting scenes look very good and the character got some depth.
Superman: Obviously he doesn't stay dead the whole movie. But who thought he would? He appears in the last third of the movie and i think he performance was good. But I'm just not a big fan of Superman over all, so i mb would have liked the movie more without him.
now to the new guys: Aquaman: for me he is the character with the most problems. I mean, Jason Mamoa is great and he looks awesome and stylish. But he lacks any backstory.. he is just there.. I felt he was kinda disconnected, and he would have needed a little more screen time for his backstory.
The Flash: He is the guy who basically lightens up the mood with some jokes from time to time. I think he was kinda believable. The only thing i didn't like was that its not sure how long he is the flash already. He says things like: "i never fight, basically i just push people and run away". That hints that he is the flash not for very long. But he already has a "base" and a full costume out of high tech materials which speaks against that.. Otherwise he fit in well and i liked his character.
Cyborg: He was basically the most important of the 3 new members, because he is connected to the "motherboxes". He didn't get much backstory either, but he worked for me. But i would have liked a little more screen time for him where we see what he can do, and what he cant do, which wasn't fleshed out enough for me.. kinda like "vision" in Age of Ultron, but not as much i think.
The Villains: Steppenwolf was neither a terrible villain, nor a really good one. He looked good for me and at least until Super Man arrives he looked dangerous and strong. Of course his background was not fleshed out very well. Also he mentions the name "darkside", but nothing else is mentioned above his connection to darkside. Also for me at least it was not 100% clear who exactly he was talking to when he talked to "mother". Did he talk to the boxes? Or is "mother" a real "person"?
He was pretty generic, like most comic book movie villains until now, but nothing too bad.
Overall i enjoyed the movie even if it has flaws.
And i think all those 1-Star ratings are from hatetrain people who already hated on BvS too much..
But its not a 10-Star movie either.