Important, highly provocative drama.

Rating: 10/10 (16 June 2003)

Somewhat forgotten nowadays, this nevertheless remains a masterful, important movie about the accountability of German judges (and others of influence) for their "crimes against humanity" during the Third Reich.
The thoughtful, intelligent script is delivered with purpose and passion by an impressive line-up of actors. Maximillian Schell (Oscar-winning) and Richard Widmark are forceful and magnetic as the counsels for defence and prosecution, respectively. Other stand out performances come from Judy Garland and Montgomery Clift (extraordinary) as two highly sympathetic trial witnesses. However, top billing goes to Spencer Tracy, whose role as the presiding judge of the trial is perfectly suited to his skillful, unselfish style.
Film is a surprisingly well-balanced argument, allowing numerous points of view to influence the audience's perception throughout the 3 hours. Though filmed in black and white, the moral and political contexts within are anything but; indeed, as the implications of the trial broaden in scope, the screenplay becomes extremely provocative and asks some very challenging questions.
Overall technical credits are outstanding and as such, ensure the film's focused, exciting delivery. Lasting impression after viewing is one of anger and fascination, compelling the audience to discuss this dark chapter in recent history. If only for that, everyone should make an effort to see this movie at least once.