A cinematic punch to the gut

Rating: 8/10 (12 August 2009)

I have not read the novel, so I can't comment on whether or not it is a faithful adaptation. This is a dark and bleak look at war, with the brutality of it not being based on violence, blood or gore, which is not abundant in this. Instead, this explores the impact it has on the mind, and it is a truly chilling and devastating story. The plot is well-told, and the similarity to Full Metal Jacket is obvious, without detracting from the viewing(I wouldn't call it "enjoyment", and that certainly wasn't what the two directors went for) of either film. I believe this is the first time I've seen something helmed by Mendes, though I have been wanting to watch his work for a long time, and now I definitely will make sure to pursue more of it. The tone is unpleasant, and the experience of this is often suffocating. You feel trapped. This stares you right in the face and never blinks. The acting is excellent all the way. Pacing is impeccable. The cinematography and editing are incredible. I don't know how much of this is accurate and true to life, but it doesn't come off as exaggerated. This is highly psychological, and in that regard, is completely credible. The music is spot-on. While it is frequent, the narration doesn't come off as a crutch. There is near-constant strong language, as well as a bit of sexuality/nudity. I recommend this to anyone who is interested in how a battlefield affects the soldiers. 8/10