They read the book

Rating: 7/10 (2 February 2008)

I didn't read the book so unlike the others I can only comment on the movie. It was long, but I watched it all, and that's says something. I have no idea where that river came from in the end making it impossible for (what's his name) to get back. Was that river newly formed? I hate hunters and don't think the killing of a moose was worth his 'experience'. You wouldn't think so either if you were the moose. The scenery was beautiful and the music set a nice tone. The performances were all good, especially Hal Holbrook, a kind lonely old man with no one to love. But 'what's his face' didn't care about anybody or anything. He hurts everyone he knows with his childish "the worlds a bad place" attitude. As if it's something only he notices. Da grow up dude. It's the happiness you give others that make life count for something. How about just go save a dog. there's enough of those that need love.