Extremely impressive depiction of a controversial, ambiguous narrative

Rating: 9/10 (21 February 2018)

Coming from a perspective of knowing relatively little about the Harding scandal, I'm very impressed by the way Gillespie attacks the challenging and controversial topic. Robbie delivers a phenomenal performance, one of the best of the year, and Janney also does a very good job. What is so difficult is the contradictory narratives given by the media, Tonya, and Gillooy. Rather than piece them together and frame it as a clean, neat narrative, Gillespie turns it on its head by emphasizing the contradictions and how truth as a concept and particularly in popular culture is so loaded and complex. Devices such as split screens and breaking the fourth wall are employed effectively to underscore the fuzzy nature of truth. The way Tonya's character is explained and built up is also very well done and allows you to really connect with her emotionally and understand how the events unfolded. The ending was truly heart wrenching, and in general the movie did an excellent job of staying true to how things really unfolded. The script and direction both blew me away and were among the best of the year. Very impressive and well-rounded depiction of a crazy true story, with Robbie leading the way.