3 rules, they're more like guidelines actually...

Rating: 9/10 (10 August 2004)

I have seen I,Robot and liked it. It's a shame if someone didn't like it, I think it mostly to blame on the fact that we (sci-fi fans) already have seen thesame things before. If you can step over that and see the movie for what it is I,robot is a great movie even with some creative aspects.
If you cannot it's just an average movie, with thesame loner/cop who hates technology/robots is not believed by his boss/other people (otherwise it would be a short film !). though still a good movie it would never be as new or innovative as 20 some years ago when these rules where just being invented/drawn up. I do however agree that more could have been done to make I,robot really awesome.
Will Smith did good in his part as the loner, who played a gritty detective though he is still not as experienced as say Harrison Ford in Blade Runner.people seemingly have a hard time seeing him in a more serious role I suppose.
9/10 for the entertainment factor, gorgeous enviroment and If you can overlook the sometimes obvious a great Asimov inspired story.