An Experiment

Rating: 5/10 (29 July 2008)

A truly experimental film made by a major artist. It's too long, some of it is unnecessary, there are few musical scenes that truly impress or inspire, but it does contain a very impressive Cate Blanchett, Heath Ledger's penis preserved on film, a ravishing 60's version of Michelle Williams, a fine and surprisingly sharp performance by Marcus Carl Franklin and an interesting idea. The Richard Gere scenes are completely unnecessary, meandering and take much away from the film, not that it is his fault as an performer. It's just a poor idea. Julianne Moore, a wonderful actress and a Haynes regular, has a limited role, but as usual she does it well. I had hopes of being blown away, but it didn't even come close. Too bad it doesn't really work when all is said and done, but it is worth seeing for those who are tolerant or fans of Blanchett.