Delivers

Rating: 7/10 (5 September 2005)

Don't get me wrong, I saw the movie and I liked it, because it was meant to be liked and this worked: Beautiful and likable leads and supporting actors, very romantic message, some comedy, quite a good script.
TADA! Here the critique: 1. We hear Alex was just dating girls without committing. So how did that work? Was he all honest and told them he wanted to have sex and not a serious relationship? Or was he just like Vance? 2. Sarah never had a serious relationship, because of her sister. Yeah right. And here is the dilemma - these confident beautiful people are cast to deal with everyday problems. I don't mind that in the end it's "boy gets girl", and I know nobody would see these movies if they would cast nobodies so right now I don't know how to resolve this. But because of the aforementioned to inconsistencies my rating was 7.