A Good film, but Jet Li fans may be disappointed

Rating: 8/10 (10 June 2004)

For starters, I've heard many a rumour that a 120+ cut of this film exists, but finding this elusive cut has become hard and suffice to say that I purchased the 98min cut that supposedly will screen in US cinemas soon, as I was sick of waiting to see this epic.
Fans of Hong Kong/kung Fu flicks will flock to see this one but some (mainly American) ones of Jet Li may well be disappointed in the final product. I only say 'American' fans because he has created a big action orientated following in the US with films such as 'Kiss of the Dragon' and "Cradle to the Grave' etc. Having said that though, even fans of his HK exploits may be disappointed too. This is no 'Tai Chi Master' or 'Once Upon a Time in China' for example.
Jet is indeed 'restrained' in this film, as are ALL the players. This movie is not about crazy, OTT action scenes. It will NOT deliver for hardcore kung fu fans. It's not supposed too though, that's the point. This is a film that is amazingly stylish that plays on drama rather than action. Even though you can watch the stunningly beautiful Maggie Cheung 'duce it out' with 'ol Jet it all comes across as style over substance way too often. I think that the American advertisements are a tad misleading in the fact you're going to see see a swordsmen's epic, and besides a exciting fight involving Jet and Donnie Yen, you won't really, but fans of HK cinema must still see this movie. It has a disappointing ending for sure and it really doesn't provide what it promises. It's a great film, unfortunately, it isn't as brilliant as some (including myself) would have hoped for. It's style over substance is basically it's downfall.
It's comparsion to 'Crouching Tiger Hidden Dragon' is unfounded in my opinion. Although it is enjoyable for film lovers out there, it doesn't really come close to the quality of CTHD and audiences will definitely see that. See it for Maggie Cheung's performance and come away with what you will.