A Noble Attempt -- Contains Spoilers!

Rating: 9/10 (24 November 2001)

Yes, everyone and their mother has commented on this story. So here's my two bits. ody Americans can't shut up, can they?!] As you can see in the title, I believed that the film was indeed a noble attempt.

As a fan with far too much Harry Potter trivia ingrained in my grey matter, and oddly enough, looking like an adult HP, I am the worst possible movie goer for this film: a picky and obsessed fanatic. My comments on the details: Harry has GREEN eyes. I really missed that detail. And the Dursleys were far too kind. They were over-the-top in the book, which added to the satirical humor that makes Rowling's books so enjoyable. I did agree with the cutting of the Norbert scene: it was a small detail touched in later books, but is unimportant in the storytelling. I wish that there was more interaction with the twins. I did see them as a bit more muscular, but they were adorable, so I forgave. And Captain Oliver .. WOOF! 'nuff said. But enough of that.
The story overall was very faithful. The film lagged only when changes were made. The Quiddich game was a spectacular treat, BUT it was a bit over the top. Shades of Home Alone, of course. But I can forgive that, because it was a spectacular event. The attacking keys were a bit much for me in the end.. more Home Alone. Harry was a bit too mean in the beginning. Part of the joy of the Harry Potter is that it is a coming of age story. He begins as a quiet, weak little boy, thrust into a world of magic. And misconceptions are given of the Dursleys. Duddley-wudkins jumping on the staircase forcing Harry to join them for his birthday? The hatred between them wasn't as clear as it could have been. Malfoy was well done, though a distinct sexual desire/tension could be felt. Interesting. Emma Watson shines as Hermione Granger. Though she looks a bit too pretty in my mind. But no one's perfect!
A note on the special effects: though some say they stunk, I didn't care either way. Some moments could have been cut. The 30 second moving brick wall could have been cut. It went on and on. Just spend five seconds opening the wall. That's it. Finis. The story is so wonderful that there is no need to "dazzle" the audience. Most of the f/x were well done and spent just enough time. But the aforementioned effect was my only main qualm. The chess game was brilliant!
But overall, the film was well done. It focused much time on the "exciting" moments, which is fine for a film. Harry Potter #1 is the weakest book in the series, in my opinion, anyway. I'm quite curious as to how they'll be able to cut down book four though! EEK. Anyway, the film is definitely worth watching. For HP virgins -- it's worth it as well. My virginal friends saw it and loved it as well. :) Just go when there won't be snivelling little brats to halt your joy.